We'd like to recommend you the best products! We may get a small share of the sale should you buy something through our recommendation links.

The 3 Best Proctor Silex Toaster Ovens of 2021: Top Rated Models

Best Proctor Silex toaster oven

Since its founding in 1960 in the United States, Proctor-Silex has become synonymous with fine engineering and unique product development – a fact that has enabled it to stay atop of every cooking enthusiast’s wishlist over the last couple of decades.

This manufacturer’s iconic toaster oven models from back in the 80s and 90s are also said to inspire some of the best retro-style toaster ovens in the marketplace today. As a matter of fact, lots of cooking shows have declared Proctor Silex toaster ovens as some of the best they have ever come across.

Having said that, the company has designed hundreds of thousands (if not millions) of kitchen appliances over the years and while it strives to ensure that all its products perform as advertised, it has created more than a few lemons along the way. This realization turns the simple selection process into a seemingly impossible task, and that is why I decided to take it upon myself and jump in to help. I’ve been reviewing toaster ovens for years now, and I’m confident that my experience has given me a unique ability to quickly separate the best cooking appliances from the rest. With this skill in hand, I ventured into the marketplace to spend a couple of days reviewing all Proctor Silex toaster ovens so I could create this ultimate review of their 3 best models.

Without wasting any more of your time, let us skip to the main section of the post and look at the three best Proctor Silex toaster ovens you should acquire today.

The Top 3 Best Proctor Silex Toaster Ovens in 2021

Toaster Oven NameWeightTimerDimensionsSlicePrice
Toaster Oven Multi-Function8.53 lbsYes8.07 x 15.2 x 11.3 in4 Check Price
Black 4-Slice Toaster Oven2.68 lbsYes16.2 x 13.6 x 9.7 in4 Check Price
4-Slice Toaster Oven14 lbsYes18.2 x 14.4 x 9.5 in4 Check Price

Proctor Silex Toaster Oven #1:

  • If like me, you have a huge family and like hosting frequent parties at your home, then allow me to introduce you to one of the best reliable toaster ovens out there. The unit has been fitted with 1100 watts of power that will allow it to handle anything your family throws in it.
  • When the unit arrived from Amazon, I decided to use it to prepare cookies for a party that was coming up the following weekend. I knew that if I didn’t like the first batch it delivered (or if its results were not delicious) then I would simply toss it aside and go back to my good old toaster oven. The fact that the unit has made it into this enumeration, however, implies that its performance more than exceeded my standards. It stayed on for hours on end and did not slow down even once it the duration.
  • During the party, I also noticed that Proctor-Silex 31260 Toaster Oven retails with cool to the touch exteriors. If you’re new to the realm of kitchen appliances and do not know what a cool to the touch exterior implies, it simply means that regardless of how long the appliance stays in operation, its outer surface will not get hot even one bit. This, in turn, protects everyone in the household from any serious burn injuries.
  • While still on the subject of its safety features, I’d like to touch on what makes the unit cool to the touch, because the feature also has a second advantage. To make sure that hot air does not reach the outer surface, the manufacturer has perfectly insulated the walls, and that also means that all the hot air trapped inside the unit will cook your meals faster.
  • Inside the package you will receive from Amazon, you will find several accessories including, but not limited to an oven rack for broiling, and a bake pan for baking and toasting. These are there to improve your flexibility in the kitchen and they are also dishwasher safe, so you won’t be stressed out when it’s time to clean the appliance’s parts.

Notable features:

  • Easy to use even for total beginners
  • Very versatile
  • From a reputable brand
  • Accessories have been included in the package
  • The feet are anti-skid even on wet surfaces
  • Do you think that the Proctor Silex model we just looked at is too “simple” and you’d like a model that would be more noticeable on your kitchen counter? Then this Hamilton Beach, Black Proctor Silex 31118R Toaster Oven has been designed with your exact needs in mind.
  • Thanks to its sleek design, you can rest assured that once the unit is on your kitchen counter, everyone who walks in will have something positive to say about the build. I gifted this unit to my friend on her birthday and she has told me that since then, two of her friends have decided to invest in a similar model after seeing hers on her kitchen counter. Other than its sleek design, it also easily qualifies as one of the easiest to clean toaster ovens out there today.
  • In the package you will receive from Amazon, you’ll find a removable crumb tray. If you’re new to the realm of toaster ovens and don’t know what a removable crumb tray is, it’s simply the part of the tool responsible for collecting all the dirt and debris that fall off of your cooked meals. To clean the crumb tray, all you ought to do is empty its contents into a sink or bin, and wipe it off using a clean, damp cloth.
  • The once-in-a-month, thorough cleaning sessions won’t stress you out either, thanks to the fact that the interior has been covered with a non-stick material that will allow you to effortlessly wipe off the dirt from it. Here is a detailed guide on how to clean the interior of your toaster oven. Regardless of the cleaning method you will choose from the guide, the cleaning sessions won’t even take 10 minutes to complete.
  • Another feature I ought to mention of the appliance is its portability. When it was time to test the unit, I was watching one of my favorite TV programs and didn’t feel like leaving the comfort of my couch to go into the kitchen just for a test session.
  • What did I do? I simply went and brought the unit into my living room and decided to test it from there. The unit’s compact design, lightweight nature, and extra-long power cord ensured that I did not run into any issues.

Notable features:

  • Accessories included in the package from Amazon
  • Lightweight and portable
  • Compact to save on kitchen counter space
  • Fitted with an automatic shut off feature and ready bell signal
  • Boasts an extra-large interior
  • The feet are anti-skid even on wet surfaces
  • Has a power cord storage underneath

Proctor Silex Toaster Oven #3:

  • The last, but by no means the least Proctor Silex toaster oven we’re going to look at in today’s guide is the Proctor Silex 31117. This unit’s unique selling proposition is the fact that it has been backed by a 2-year limited warranty. If this does not prove that the manufacturing company has faith in the product they are selling you, then I do not know what will.
  • Anyway, with the warranty in mind, the second thing I needed to confirm about the appliance after the package’s arrival from Amazon was its consistency. To test this, I went out, acquired 45 loaves of bread, and decided to toast every single slice using the appliance back-to-back (and without letting the appliance rest in between.)
  • What were the results? Well, the fact that the unit made it into this enumeration is proof that its ability to deliver exceeded my standards. The last slice to go inside the appliance came out just as perfectly and evenly toasted as the first one to go in. It delivered each batch of toasties in less than three minutes, which is actually as fast as some of the fastest toaster ovens out there today.

Notable features:

  • Backed by a 2-year limited warranty
  • Boasts an auto shut off feature
  • Retails with a removable crumb tray for easy cleanup
  • Large enough to accommodate a 9-inch cake pan
  • Easy to use and clean
  • Has a power cord storage underneath


If I had to pick from the three products above, I’d pick the first, Proctor-Silex 31260 as my favorite Proctor Silex toaster oven model at the moment. Note though, my decision isn’t because the other units cannot match up in terms of performance. Actually, quite the opposite. I loved the Proctor-Silex 31260 model because its design and color combination appealed to my personal preferences more and I think that it will perfectly complement my kitchen interior décor.

With that in mind, if you had already settled on a different product from the list, I’d like to urge you to stick with it because it could be just the unit that changes your cooking life forever.

And what will be the best Proctor Silex toaster oven in 2022? If you are interested in this subject subscribe us and share your opinion in a comment. Thank you!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.