We'd like to recommend you the best products! We may get a small share of the sale should you buy something through our recommendation links.

The 6 Best Black Toaster Ovens of 2021: Top Rated Models

Best black toaster oven

When it comes to countertop kitchen appliances, something is reassuring about the best black toaster ovens. They can all do one thing and do it very well – consistently serving up beautifully browned meals from pizzas and casseroles to cakes and toasts.

To come up with this ultimate review, I toasted hundreds of artisan bread slices to find the five best and five worst black toaster ovens. I scored each slice against an industry-standard toast color chart with nine different colors ranging from light to burnt. Only models that delivered perfect results (consistently) made it into this review, so whichever product you pick, you can rest assured it will meet your kitchen needs and requirements.

With that in mind, let’s skip to the main section and see which model will appeal to your personal preferences. And if you’re having a hard time making a final, educated decision by the end of the post, I’ll give you my personal recommendation.

The Top 6 Best Black Toaster Ovens in 2021

Toaster Oven NameWeightTimerDimensionsSlicePrice
Oster Toaster Oven20.3 lbsYes16.3 x 19.7 x 11.3 in4 Check Price
Countertop Toaster Oven23.6 lbsYes18.7 x 15.8 x 11.6 in4 Check Price
6-Slice Toaster Oven16.46 lbsYes19 x 15.6 x 10.8 in6 Check Price
Smart Oven Pro 22.8 lbsYes18.5 x 14.5 x 11 in6 Check Price
Digital Toaster Oven16.21 lbsYes18.98 x 15.6 x 10.79 in4 Check Price
Countertop Toaster Oven8.13 lbsYes13.5 x 9 x 8 in4 Check Price

Black Toaster Oven #1:

  • This Oster Toaster Oven comes from one of the best toaster oven brands out there today. It’s sleek and stylish design coupled with its astounding working capability also makes it one of the best high-end toaster ovens I’ve ever tested.
  • That said, the only issue with this masterpiece that most verified customers complained about is the fact that it is not very easy to use for total beginners – but it can be expected from a product equipped with a lot of functions like Oster Toaster Oven.
  • For starters, the unit is equipped with advanced features like defrosting and convection bake settings, both of which will improve your flexibility in the kitchen. So, if you’re a beginner, it’s true that there will be a slight learning curve. But once you get the hang of it and become familiar with all the settings, I promise you’ll thank me for introducing this Oster Toaster Oven to you. Cooking functions included in this unit are pizza, defrost, warm, broil, bake, toast, and convection bake. The convection bake simply implies that the appliance retails with an inbuilt fan that will blow hot air around inside the appliance for even and fast cooking. If you do not know how and when to use this setting, here is a beginner’s guide on how to bake using a toaster oven. It will give you a rough idea.
  • If you tend to leave your home in a hurry every morning because you regularly wake up late or your toaster took long to prepare your toasties, it will come to your rescue as well. This masterpiece could deliver perfectly and evenly browned meals in less than two minutes, thanks to its heating elements made of materials of the highest quality.
  • The appliance has also been perfectly insulated to ensure that no hot air escapes through the surfaces. This means that all the hot air will be trapped inside the appliance, which will result in faster cook times. There is a second advantage of good insulation on a toaster oven. Since the heat isn’t reaching the exterior surface, then it (the surface) always remains cool to the touch, which in turn protects anyone who comes into contact with the appliance. This feature should be consisted of the appliance you pick, especially if you have children in your household.
  • If you hate cleaning as much as I do, then I know that picking a black toaster oven that also qualifies as one of the best easy to clean toaster ovens. It retails with a dishwasher safe and removable crumb tray, that will collect all the crumbs and debris that fall off your cooked meals. And to clean the tool, all you need to do is take out the tray, empty its content into a bid or sink, wipe it clean using a damp clothing, and let it out to dry. For thorough cleaning procedures that happen around once every four weeks, here is a guide on how to clean the interior of a toaster oven. Just note, while cleaning your toaster oven, ensure you do not come into direct contact with the heating elements. That can easily damage them.
  • Other features of the appliance worth noting are its power, spacious interior, timer, temperature range, and auto shut off feature. The spacious interior will allow it to accommodate the needs of your family, whereas the 1300 watts of power will ensure it prepares the meals without a hassle. Regarding the other three features, when the time you had set runs out, the toaster oven will automatically switch off to avoid overcooking and keep your meal warm until you get it out of the appliance.

Notable features:

  • Delivers delicious cookies, casseroles, and pizza
  • Has a cool to the touch exterior
  • Boasts a sleek and modern design
  • Accessories like a baking pan will be included in the package
  • Comes with a digital control you can use to choose among 7 cooking settings
  • Durable and sturdy
  • The feet are anti-skid even on slippery surfaces
  • Easy to clean and use

Black Toaster Oven #2:

  • If you’re scouring the internet trying to find the best unique toaster oven, then this Calphalon Countertop Toaster Oven could be what you’re looking for. It’s still on my kitchen countertop to this day and anyone who walks in there always has something to say about the appliance’s sleek design.
  • In addition to its aesthetics, it also boasts heating elements of the highest quality. They will deliver meals 40 percent faster compared to regular toaster ovens. But worry not. When you pick from the 11 cooking settings, the appliance will automatically adjust the temperature and time required to ensure perfect results. These 11 coking settings include dehydrate, defrost, keep warm, reheat, cookies, pizza, broil, roast, bake, bagel, and toast.

Notable features:

  • Durable and sturdy
  • Boasts the most unique design
  • The removable crumb tray makes it easy to clean
  • Will cook foods 40 percent faster
  • Has a large interior capacity
  • Fitted with a high contrast LCD

Black Toaster Oven #3:

  • If durability is your go-to feature when you’re choosing a kitchen appliance, then I urge you to not look further than this COMFEE’ CFO-CC2501 Toaster Oven. This stroke of genius boasts a strong build, thanks to its high-end stainless-steel finish.
  • Better yet, I have a friend who has been using the appliance for the past two years. And when I reached out to him for insights before coming up with the final list, he said that his unit has never run into any issues. The fact it retails in three different colors (black, stainless steel, and white) also allowed him to pick the tool in the color that best compliments his kitchen interior décor.

Notable features:

  • Is backed by one-year product warranty
  • Compact to save on space
  • Retails in three different colors
  • Has a durable build
  • Easy to use even for total beginners

Black Toaster Oven #4:

  • This review would be incomplete without a masterpiece from Breville, which is one of the most renowned kitchen appliance brands in the market today. But why this specific Breville Smart Pro Toaster Oven? Well, for starters, it retails with 10 preset cooking functions, including slow cook, warm, reheat, cookies, pizza, broil, roast, bake, bagel and toast.
  • The bagel setting will permit you to toast only one side of your meals. It has also been fitted with Element IQ heating elements, which are heating elements of the highest quality out there today.

Notable features:

  • Retails in two different colors
  • Powerful to handle anything you throw in it
  • Has been fitted with 10 pre-set cooking functions
  • Its heating elements are of the highest quality
  • Highly durable
  • From a reputable brand

Black Toaster Oven #5:

  • The first thing that attracted me to this masterpiece is the fact it comes with a one-year warranty and six removable and dishwasher safe accessories, including a rack clamp, baking pan, baking rack, rotisserie kit & filter, and removable crumb tray.
  • The warranty signifies that the brand has faith in the product they’re selling you, and after putting it to the test, I witnessed why. During my testing sessions, Toshiba AC25CEW-BS Toaster Oven delivered perfectly and evenly toasted slices in less than 2 minutes and maintained the consistency, even after using it for five hours non-stop.

Notable features:

  • Easy to clean
  • Exterior surface remains cool to the touch during operations
  • Will compliment any kitchen interior décor
  • Versatile
  • Comes with accessories to improve its flexibility
  • Backed by a one-year warranty

Black Toaster Oven #6:

  • If you’re scouring the internet looking for the best retro design toaster oven you can acquire for your kitchen arsenal, then I think this Willz KWS1010 Toaster Oven could be what you’re looking for. Straight out of the box, you’ll think that this masterpiece is from the 50s.
  • But don’t let that fool you into thinking that it doesn’t deliver in the toasting department. The package from Amazon will arrive with a chromed wire rack, a galvanized crumb tray, and an aluminized baking pan. All these will work together to improve your user experience.

Notable features:

  • Easy to use
  • Durable and sturdy
  • Delivered some of the most delicious toasties
  • Fitted with a thirty-minute timer
  • Interior is sufficiently spacious to accommodate a family’s needs
  • Easy to clean


I hope this review has helped you find the next best black toaster oven that will serve your household for years. If it has, then I advise that you place an order straight away while stock lasts.

However, if you are still having a hard time making a final, educated decision, then I’m still here to help you out as promised at the beginning of the post. If I were to choose from the five toaster ovens above, I’d pick the Oster Toaster Oven as my favorite black toaster oven.

It could do everything the other toaster oven models could do but was more versatile than the others. I even used it to prepare delicacies for a party I had held in my home, and it did not slow down even for a second.

And what will be the best black toaster oven in 2022? If you are interested in this subject subscribe us and share your opinion in a comment. Thank you!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.