We'd like to recommend you the best products! We may get a small share of the sale should you buy something through our recommendation links.

6 Best Toastmaster Toasters of 2021

Best Toastmaster toaster

When it comes to choosing the best Toastmaster toasters out there, I really had to give it my best and be picky because, honestly speaking, there are lots of worthy contenders I had to go through.

The company designs one of the widest arrays of toasters in a number of different styles. That said, I tried to be diligent enough and ensure to at least include products that can serve everyone, regardless of the toasting needs and requirements.

If you are in the marketplace looking for the fastest toaster, you’ll find it here. If you want the best four-slice toaster, it is actually the first one in the enumeration. Whatever standards you have in mind, you can rest assured that this detailed review has got you covered.

Better yet, other than just dedicating hours to reading about hundreds of Toastmaster toasters, I went a step further and placed an order for approximately 15 of the best I found and tested them further. Below is a synopsis of my testing sessions.

When the toasters arrived on my doorstep from Amazon, the first thing I checked was how well they complimented my kitchen interior décor. You won’t be using your toaster most time of the day. But even then, it should serve a purpose. And that is where the best aesthetic toasters come into play.

Toasters that passed in that department moved on to the second testing session. In the second session, I was testing the toaster’s slots’ ability to accommodate the thickest bread slices as well as how well and evenly they toasted them.

I went to the store and acquired the thickest bagels, croissants, English muffins, and artisan bread slices I could find. Only those toasters that could accommodate the thickest slices made it to our final list.

The other thing I tested diligently was the ability of each toaster to stay consistent even after operating continuously for hours.

As you can see, I really went all out to ensure I only present appliances that can keep serving your family for years to come.

So, without wasting any more of your time, let us skip to the main section of the post and look at the best Toastmaster toasters you can invest in today.

The Top 6 Toastmaster Toasters in 2021

Toaster NameWeightTimerDimensionsSlicePrice
4 Slice Toaster5 lbsYes10.4 x 10.8 x 7.3 in4 Check Price
4-Slice Cool Touch Toaster5 lbsYes16 x 12 x 16 in4 Check Price
Stainless Steel Toaster2.4 lbsYes10 x 6.5 x 6.5 in2 Check Price
2-Slice Fast Toaster3.95 lbsYes10 x 6.2 x 8.2 in2 Check Price
2-Slice Cool Touch Toaster2 lbsYes14 x 8 x 11.7 in2 Check Price
Stainless-Steel 4-Slice Toaster5.71 lbsYes12.9 x 12.1 x 8.5 in4 Check Price

Toastmaster Toasters #1:

  • As always, I like to start my posts on a high note. And with that in mind, allow me to introduce you the Toastmaster TM-43TS 4 Slice Toaster, best suited for those who are scouring the internet trying to find the best Toastmaster toaster that can serve a big household.
  • The first feature of this masterpiece I would like to point out is its dual controls (as you can see in its image above.) For those who are not accustomed to this feature, I’ll explain it briefly. It allows you to use the two slots on the right side to toast a specific meal (say normal bread slices) using the regular toast function while at the same time using the other two slots on the left side to prepare an entirely different meal (say bagel slices) using the bagel setting. Sounds futuristic, doesn’t it?
  • In addition to that, the slots are extra wide and extra-long to fit in slices of all sizes and shapes. And when the slices have been readily toasted, simply press the high lift lever on the front side to lift the slices high enough to retrieve them without burning your fingers. Always note that the steel around the slots gets excessively hot during operations.
  • To boost the toaster’s versatility, Toastmaster has also fitted extra settings in this appliance. These are the cancel, reheat, and bagel.
  • The reheat setting will allow you to warm up your leftover toasties without browning them any further whereas the bagel setting permits you to toast only the cut side of your bagel slices. What’s more? The bagel setting toasts your slices in a way that the outside becomes crusty, but the inside remains soft and warm.
  • As a toast lover myself, I also understand that the level you want your toasties prepare will vary from time to time: and that is where the six different toasting levels come into play. The first level delivers lightly toasted slices whereas the seventh level delivers darkly toasted slices.
  • If you are new to toasters, then I recommend you start by using the second or third settings. This way, if it is okay, you just found out what works for you. And if it isn’t sufficiently toasted, you will still have the opportunity to put it back into the appliance and toast it a little bit longer. Keep doing this until you ultimately find a toasting level that best meets your toasting needs and requirements.
  • To make sure your slices always come out perfectly and evenly toasted, Toastmaster has also fit Toaster with self-centering bread guides. These will position the slices in a manner that allows them to receive the perfect amount of heat, resulting in evenly toasted slices.
  • And if you tend to have children running around your kitchen every time you are preparing breakfast, then I am confident the cool to the touch exterior will come in handy. This feature allows the toaster to remain cool regardless of how long the toaster has been in operation, which will, in turn, protect anyone who accidentally comes into contact with the appliance.

Notable features:

  • The removable crumb tray included makes the appliance easy to clean
  • Self-centering bread guides available to help you prepare perfectly toasted slices at all times
  • Retails with a high-lift lever that will protect your fingers from burn injuries
  • The four slots are wide and long enough to accommodate bread slices of all sizes and shapes
  • The tool comes with six different toasting levels that will accommodate everyone’s taste in your family
  • The exterior surface remains cool to the touch after operations
  • Easy to use

Toastmaster Toasters #2:

  • If you are tired of having to wait for your family members to prepare their toasties each morning before you can get your turn and are looking for the best basic four-slice toaster to meet your toasting needs, then look no further than this Toastmaster 4-Slice Cool Touch Toaster.
  • In fact, given it is a four-slice toaster, I have to say that it doesn’t take up too much space on the counter. Its color combination also allows it to seamlessly blend in with any kitchen interior décor. To top it off, it is very durable and will keep serving your family for years to come if you take good care of it.
  • The best feature of the toaster is definitely the dual control panels. You can prepare two different meals at the same time for two people using diverse settings.

Notable features:

  • Compact for a four-slice toaster
  • Will blend in with and compliment any kitchen interior décor
  • Retails with six different browning levels you can pick from
  • Has a bagel function
  • The slots are wide and long enough
  • The exterior surface remains cool to the touch
  • If you live alone and are looking for the best 2-slice toaster that can deliver toasties in a timely manner, I think this Toastmaster TM-22TS 2 Slice Stainless Steel Toaster is exactly what you are looking for.
  • I bought it as a graduation present for one of my friends who was venturing into the corporate world and to this day, he is head over heels in love with the appliance. It can deliver two, perfectly toasted slices in less than 2 minutes, which implies you won’t ever have to leave your house late or with an empty stomach because breakfast took long to prepare.
  • This toaster also boasts extra-wide self-centering slots that place your slices in a way that allows them to come out perfectly and evenly toasted that can be perfect for even artisan or homemade bread slices.

Notable features:

  • The slide-out crumb tray makes it easy to clean
  • The extra toast lift will protect your fingers from burns
  • Six different browning levels to pick from
  • Slots are extra wide
  • Very versatile
  • Space-saving

Toastmaster Toasters #4:

  • Just as its name suggests, Toastmaster 2-Slice Fast Toaster is one of the fastest toasters money can buy today. It can deliver perfectly toasted slices in less than 2 minutes while at the same time using minimal power. It is 50% faster than traditional toaster, being perfect for those busy mornings.
  • The slots are also extra wide to fit in bread slices of all sizes and shapes. What’s more? They have been fitted with self-centering guides. And when your slices have been sufficiently toasted, you only have to press the high-lift lever to raise them high. In case you can retrieve them without coming into contact with the hot slots, preventing burn injuries.

Notable features:

  • Very fast
  • Includes a slide-out crumb tray
  • Very versatile
  • Multiple browning levels included
  • Boasts self-centering guides
  • Slots are extra wide and extra-long
  • After checking out Toastmaster TM-24TS 2-Slice Cool Touch Toaster’s features online, I was convinced that it is an outstanding 2-slice toaster. And then I saw that the company was offering a one-year limited warranty, I had to place an order right away. This shows that the company has faith in their products.
  • And as expected, when the package arrived and I put it through a series of testing sessions, it performed exceptionally. I used the toaster to toast three loaves of bread continuously and the last slice that went into the appliance came out just as delicious as the first one that went in.

Notable features:

  • Retails with a one-year limited warranty
  • Easy to clean and use
  • The slots are wide and long enough
  • The exterior surface remains cool to the touch during operations
  • Compact to save on space
  • Lightweight and portable
  • The last, but by no means the least toaster from Toastmaster in our enumeration is the Toastmaster Stainless-Steel 4-Slice Toaster. Straight out of the box, you can tell that this masterpiece easily qualifies as one of the best modern toasters thanks to its state of the art features and additions.
  • The first thing you will notice on this appliance is its digital display, which allows you to see the amount of time remaining before your toasted slices are ready for consumption. Better yet, in case like me, you tend to get carried away while preparing your breakfast, this appliance has got you covered as well. When the slices are ready, the appliance will let out a beep sound that will notify you to retrieve the slices.
  • And that is not all that it has to offer. Unlike most four-slice toasters you will come across today, this Toastmaster toaster also boasts four other toasting settings you can avail. These include reheat, frozen, bagel, and cancel. The only setting I haven’t talked about there is the frozen option, which allows you to toast frozen bread slices in a timely manner, without having to wait for them to thaw first.
  • Just like the other four-slice toaster we looked at earlier at the beginning of the post, Toastmaster Stainless-Steel 4-Slice Toaster also boasts dual controls that will come in handy if you want to prepare two different meals at the same time for two different people.

Notable features:

  • Retails with a digital display
  • Looks good with any kitchen interior décor
  • When the slices are ready, the appliance will notify you
  • Retails with six different browning levels to accommodate everyone’s taste in your family
  • Very versatile
  • The slots are wide and long enough to fit in slices of all sizes
  • The exterior surface remains cool to the touch during operations


After spending days researching and testing a wide array of toasters from Toastmaster, I pick the Toastmaster Stainless-Steel 4-Slice Toaster as my favorite. Note though, this doesn’t imply that the other toasters are inferior in comparison. It just implies that this toaster best met my personal needs and taste, and I’m sure this one will satisfy my whole family.

So, if you are still having a hard time making an educated final decision, feel free to try out the 4-slice model. However, if you already had your eyes set on a different appliance, don’t let me change your mind. Go ahead and place an order right away.

And what will be the best Toastmaster toaster in 2022? If you are interested in this subject subscribe us and share your opinion in a comment. Thank you!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.