We'd like to recommend you the best products! We may get a small share of the sale should you buy something through our recommendation links.

Best Toastie Makers in 2021 – The Ultimate Guide

Best toastie maker

Sandwich makers save us a lot of frustration and time, particularly when we’re trying to either make a quick meal before going to bed or early in the mornings when we’re trying to get out of the door so we are not late for work or school.

So I set out on a quest of finding the best toastie makers that can fulfill this goal then created a shortlist of five of the best in the marketplace today.

I also ensured there is something for everyone in this enumeration. If your goal is to save on space, then this list has got you covered. If your intention is to prepare sandwiches with aesthetic grill marks, then this post has got you covered as well.

In addition to that, I also kept in mind several factors while researching for this post. For instance, I knew different sandwich makers take slightly distinct sizes of bread slices. So I made an effort to test each tool with thin and medium sized slices to ensure they would fit all standard bread slices you choose to shove in there.

The reason I did not test with thick bread slices is that they do not toast as well in most toastie makers as you would love. Worst yet, using the thickest bread slices also means you will need to use fewer fillings, which is most sandwich lovers’ worst nightmare.

Without further delay, let us skip to the main section of the post and look at the best toastie makers in the marketplace today.

The Top 5 Toastie Maker in 2021

Toaster NameWeightTemp. ControlDimensionsSlicesPrice
Gotham Steel Sandwich Maker2.05 lbsYes12x12x6 in2 Check Price
Proctor Silex 25408Y Sandwich Toaster3.88 lbsYes4.6x10.4x11 in2 Check Price
OVENTE 3-in-1 Electric Sandwich Maker 5.05 lbsYes11.4x7.1x4.8 in2 Check Price
Hamilton Beach Sandwich Maker, 4", BLACK3.44 lbsYes10.8x11.2x4.1 in2 Check Price
T-fal Sandwich and Waffle Maker, Silver4.5 lbsYes12.7x11.9x6.8 in2 Check Price

Toastie Maker #1:

  • If you have been on the hunt for the best toastie maker for a long time, then there is a high probability you have come across the brand “Gotham”. This company has been around for years now, and most, if not all buyers of their products are satisfied by the quality and reliability they provide.
  • So it makes total sense I would include a product from the brand in this enumeration. Boasting a durable construction and high-end materials, Gotham Steel Sandwich Maker is a toaster and electric Panini grill retailing with an ultra-nonstick copper surface.
  • The non-stick feature ensures sandwiches you prepare do not stick to the upper side of the appliance. The tool can also prepare 2 sandwiches at a time, which is sufficient if you live alone or with a roommate.
  • It can also serve a bigger family since it delivers perfectly toasted sandwiches in mere minutes. So if you want to prepare several sandwiches for multiple individuals, all you need to do is wake up a little bit earlier, and you can rest assured no one will be late for their errands.
  • Another feature worth noting is Gotham Steel Sandwich Maker’s compact feature, making it perfect for traveling and those who want to save on space.

Notable features:

  • Easy to use even for beginners
  • Compact so it doesn’t take up too much counter space
  • Easy to clean thanks to the non-stick plates
  • Delivers deliciously toasted sandwiches
  • Retails with inbuilt indicator lights to notify you when your meal is ready
  • Is your prime factor saving space in the kitchen as you look for the best toastie maker? This pint-sized toaster is the perfect choice for you. In fact, this toaster’s compact size also makes it optimal for dorm rooms as well as small apartments.
  • During my testing sessions, I also confirmed Proctor’s advertising claims that this sandwich maker can deliver some of the most delicious sandwich toasties in just a few minutes. Say no to leaving your house late anymore just because breakfast last too long to prepare.
  • Thanks to the power on and preheat lights, you can also track your meal’s toasting process as the tool will notify you when your meal is ready for consumption.
  • In regards to storage, the tool will not stand in your way. You can easily store the toaster upright in just about any corner in your kitchen counter.
  • Proctor Silex 25408Y Sandwich Toaster is versatile as well. Besides the most delicious sandwiches, you can also use this handy appliance to prepare French toasts, omelets, wafers, and other delicacies.

Notable features:

  • Includes preheat and other indicator lights that keep you posted on the toasting procedure
  • Compact size to fit in any kitchen
  • Easy to use
  • Aesthetic and will supplement your kitchen’s interior décor
  • Easy to clean
  • Create the sweetest sandwiches for breakfast, lunch, or supper for your family and friends using this OVENTE GPI302B 3-in-1 Electric Sandwich Maker. This sandwich maker boasts detachable and nonstick grill and waffle plates that will permit you to make grilled sandwiches as well as waffles without a hassle. The resulting meals also looked and tasted great.
  • If you are new to the sandwich toasting realm, then this gadget will serve you well because it is easy to use and will deliver delicious sandwiches faster as well. The lower and upper plates also heat up pretty fast.
  • To top it off, the tool retails with LED indicator lights that are in place to tell you when the plates are ready to start preparing your sandwiches. Cleaning shouldn’t stress you out either since the plates are non-stick and dishwasher safe.

Notable features:

  • Can also be used by kids thanks to its cool to touch handle
  • Boasts indicator lights to guide you through the process
  • Delivers even results even after consistent results
  • Versatile as it can prepare multiple meals
  • Aesthetic and will look great on your kitchen counter
  • In the realm of kitchen appliances, Hamilton Beach 25430 Sandwich Maker has quite a reputation for its ability to make cooking appliances that are convenient and easy to use. In fact, this company has been in existence for decades, which implies they have a pretty good knowledge of what their customers require.
  • They also release products that meet the requirements and preferences their preceding models could not, and that is also how this sandwich maker came into existence. This tool saves space and time, as it is compact and can prepare delicious toasties pretty quickly.
  • You won’t need to worry about spilled fillings since the appliance will seal off the ends completely and create beautiful grill marks on the top side.

Notable features:

  • From a reputable brand
  • Doesn’t spill fillings
  • Easy to clean the non-stick grids
  • Quick and easy to use
  • Can prepare a whole lot of foods
  • For starters, there are lots of plate sets you can collect for this toaster, which makes it a very versatile machine. It retails with waffle and sandwich making plates, which you will find nicely held in plastic containers for secure storage.
  • If you wish, you can also acquire other plates for other delicacies such as wafers, which are readily available on Amazon. Other meals you can prepare with this appliance include baby Dutch pancakes, doughnuts, pastries, French toasts, Panini, and heart-shaped waffles.
  • Because this post is dedicated to its ability to deliver the best sandwiches, I only paid attention to its sandwich plates: which are also of a decent size and are very easy to click out of place in case you need to clean or replace them.
  • They are all dishwasher safe as well, which makes them easy to clean. Even though this appliance is not the easiest to use among all equipment I tested while coming up with this enumeration, the sandwiches it delivered are, without a doubt, some of the best I have ever tasted, and the quality of the non-stick plates implies I only needed to use the thinnest coating of butter on the outside of the meals in order to attain a crispy and perfectly brown exterior.
  • The indicator lights included on the appliance will notify you when your meal is ready for consumption.

Notable features:

  • Retails with two different sets of waffle and sandwich plates
  • The plates are removable and dishwasher safe, making them easy to clean
  • Indicator lights will notify you when the meal is ready
  • Aoasts a cord storage
  • Delivers perfectly toasted sandwiches


After extensive research and testing sessions, I personally pick Hamilton Beach 25430 Sandwich Maker as my favorite toastie maker in the market in this year. This tool boasted everything needed to ensure that even beginners can make the sweetest sandwiches without a hassle. The grill marks the appliance left on my sandwiches were also amazing. And to conclude, I liked the fact that the toastie maker sealed the sides of my sandwiches so no feelings were lost.

And what will be the best toastie maker in 2022? If you are interested in this subject subscribe us and share your opinion in a comment. Thank you!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.