We'd like to recommend you the best products! We may get a small share of the sale should you buy something through our recommendation links.

6 Best Sandwich Toasters in 2021

Best sandwich toaster

I believe nothing beats a good old ham and cheese toasty as day starters. That said, why would one want to go through the effort of going out to a restaurant and get one of these when it is easier to make them in the comfort of one’s home? Shouldn’t that be what everyone strives for today?

In addition to that, learning how to prepare these meals in the comfort of your home also implies you can make as many sandwiches as you wish any days you feel like it.

Having said that, all this would be impossible to attain without the best sandwich toaster on your kitchen corner. Lucky for you, I have got you covered on that end as well. Today, I present you a detailed review of tried and tested sandwich toasters that money can buy.

So, all you ought to do now is go through the review, pick the one that best meets your needs and personal preferences, then place an order while the stock lasts.

In order to make sure every product I included in this enumeration would meet everyone’s standards, I placed an order for all the six myself and took them through a series of tests to check their evenness, consistency, durability, and most importantly, their ease of use and cleaning.

So whichever product you choose, you can rest assured that it will meet your needs and requirements.

To top it off, for those who will still have a hard time picking from the six products after reading this review, I have also included a personal recommendation at the end. Make sure you stay ‘til the end of the post.

Let us not waste anymore of your time and skip to the main section of the post.

The Top 6 Sandwich Toasters in 2021

Toaster NameWeightTimerDimensionsSlicePrice
Proctor-Silex Sandwich Maker3.13 lbsYes9.5 x 9.9 x 4 in2 Check Price
Proctor Silex Sandwich Toaster3.09 lbsYes4.59 x 10.42 x 11 in2 Check Price
Electric Panini Press Grill5.82 lbsYes4.5 x 12.3 x 12.6 in2 Check Price
Gotham Steel Sandwich Maker2.69 lbsYes12 x 12 x 6 in2 Check Price
BLACK+DECKER 3-in-1 Sandwich Maker6.25 lbsYes9 x 9 x 4 in2 Check Price
Kealive Sandwich Maker5.69 lbsYes10.83 x 14.57 x 5.51 in 2 Check Price
  • If I am being 100 percent honest with you, the first thing that attracted me to this appliance was the manufacturing brand, Proctor Silex. It is one of the best brands in the realm of kitchen appliances right now: and for a good reason.
  • To top it off, this company recently merged with Hamilton Beach, another brand that also qualifies as one of the best in the kitchen appliances world. And if all that proves anything, it’s that the companies know what their customers want and can deliver products that can meet anyone’s needs and personal preferences.
  • Having said that, let us take a look at what this specific Proctor-Silex Sandwich Maker white has to offer in the kitchen.
  • First, thanks to the chrome finish of this sandwich maker, it will look very aesthetic in any kitchen, regardless of the interior décor. The chrome finish also ensures the product’s durability, meaning that you can rest assured it will keep serving your family for years to come.
  • If your family has sandwich lovers who tend to leave in a hurry every morning for school or work, then this Proctor-Silex Sandwich Maker white has got you covered as well. Of all products I reviewed while creating this post, it was one of the fastest when it came to the heat up duration. You can have your perfect toasties in less than ten minutes each morning.
  • And in case it is your first time using a sandwich maker, this Sandwich Maker is very easy to use as well, thanks to the power on and preheat lights that have been included to guide you through every session.
  • The other feature worth noting about this appliance is its compact and lightweight nature, which makes it very portable.

Notable features:

  • Very aesthetic
  • Prepares sandwiches very fast
  • Easy to use and clean
  • Boasts a non-stick grid surface
  • Compact and lightweight, making it portable
  • Durable and very sturdy
  • The next masterpiece in our enumeration is also from Proctor Silex, which further goes on to show that the company is seasoned in this sector.
  • And just like the other Proctor Silex product we just looked at, this Sandwich Toaster did not disappoint in the toasting department.
  • It is compact and lightweight, which came in really handy because I had a small kitchen counter space to spare. And in order to save on space even more, the manufacturer designed this appliance in a way so you can store it upright in your cabinet.
  • In addition, If, like me, you hate cleaning, then you will love the fact that the gadget also retails with easy to clean non-stick plates. Most of the time, all you will need to do is take them out, use a clean cloth to wipe them clean, then put them back into the appliance.
  • And if you want to do a more thorough cleaning, then simply put the plates into the dishwasher.
  • To make the appliance easy to use, the company included easy to understand indicator lights.

Notable features:

  • Very durable and sturdy
  • Easy to clean and use
  • Compact and lightweight to take up small space and be durable
  • Delivered delicious sandwiches and waffles
  • Indicator lights included
  • I believe Hamilton Beach needs no introduction at this point as I just talked about it earlier. So, let us go ahead and look at what features earned this masterpiece a spot in this enumeration.
  • First, it was impressive when it came to making paninis and savory sandwiches. And it did it very fast as well, which came in handy in my family where everyone has to leave in a hurry each morning. If you want to warm your pizza or leftover sandwich slices without browning them any further, the lock top lid has got you covered.
  • Hamilton Beach Electric Panini Press Grill is also easy to use, thanks to the indicator lights that have been included.
  • And if red is not your color, you can get the appliance in two other colors: with a chrome finish or stainless-steel finish.

Notable features:

  • The finish is very aesthetic
  • Can reheat leftover slices without browning them any further
  • Toasts fast
  • Easy to clean and use
  • The feet are anti-slip

Sandwich Toaster #4:

  • Are you in the marketplace to find the best sandwich toaster that can deliver perfectly grilled cheese sandwiches in minutes and maintain its consistency? Then I believe that this Gotham Steel Sandwich Maker is what you are looking for.
  • Extremely easy to use. Thanks to the indicator lights that it retails with, you won’t face any issues with this appliance. It also had no problem when it came to cleanup mainly due to the non-stick plates. All you need to do is wipe them using a clean and damp cloth after they have cooled down, then you can use it again for another round.

Notable features:

  • Looks aesthetic on the kitchen counter
  • Leaves beautiful grill marks on all its bread slices
  • Easy to use and clean
  • Very fast at toasting
  • The plates’ design ensures no spillovers
  • The first thing that attracted me to this state-of-the-art sandwich toaster was the indicator lights that make it easy to use. After testing it out, my plan was to give it as a wedding gift to my sister, so the ease of use was essential.
  • It has been a couple of months now and her family is still head over heels in love with the appliance. They have also pointed out that the toaster is impressive when it comes to delivering evenly toasted slices and maintaining these results after hours of use.

Notable features:

  • Easy to use and clean
  • Delivers evenly toasted sandwiches
  • The results are consistent
  • Compact and lightweight
  • Very portable
  • Let me start by talking about Kealive Sandwich 3 in 1 Sandwich Toaster’s design. In regard to the way it looks, you will either love it or hate it, there is no in-between. As for me, I loved it, explaining why the appliance won a spot in this enumeration.
  • That said, the design was not the only thing that impressed me about this appliance. After placing an order, the sandwich toaster came with 3 interchangeable plates. These three plates can be used to prepare a wide array of meals from waffles to sandwiches. There was a plate for grilling as well.
  • And if you are a fan of larger sandwiches such as steaks and waffle iron, then the appliance has got your back as well. All you ought to ensure is that you have the required plates to carry out the task in mind.
  • To give you a better understanding of what you will be paying for, the following are the things that will come included in the package you acquire:
  1. Kealive Sandwich 3 in 1 Sandwich Toaster
  2. 2 pieces of waffle cooking plates
  3. 2 pieces of grill plates
  4. 2 pieces of sandwich plates
  5. A three-year warranty
  6. A user manual
  7. An oil collecting box
  • As you can see, that is a sweet deal. As for the 3-year warranty included, it is there to prove to you that the manufacturing company has faith in the appliance they are selling to you.
  • In addition to that, this Sandwich Toaster is also super-fast and easy to operate, even if you have no experience when it comes to operating sandwich makers.
  • As for fastness, the tool can deliver perfectly toasted sandwiches in only 3 minutes, thanks to its 750-watt power. If you tend to host parties at your household, this speed of toasting will come in handy.
  • How could I forget to mention how easy to clean this appliance? The nonstick anodized aluminum coated plates that come with the package will ensure that food will not stick to your griddle.
  • The non-stick plates can also be removed, and they are dishwasher safe, which doubles the ease of cleaning.
  • And if you have children always running around your kitchen while you prepare your breakfast, then you will love the fact that Kealive Sandwich 3 in 1 Sandwich Toaster remains cool to the touch during operations.

Notable features:

  • The exterior surface remains cool to the touch
  • Comes with a 3-year warranty
  • A user manual included
  • Very fast at preparing sandwiches
  • Easy to clean and use
  • The plates are nonstick


There you have it. My detailed and ultimate enumeration on the best sandwich toasters out there today. All you ought to do now is place an order for the one you love and kickstart your journey toward a lifetime of delicious sandwiches.

With that in mind, as I promised at the beginning of the post, I will also include my recommendation in the conclusion. If I had to choose from the six products above, I would pick the Kealive Sandwich 3 in 1 Sandwich Toaster as my favorite sandwich toaster today.

This appliance met and surpassed every standard I had in mind. Its only disadvantage was the size of toasties it delivered, but that was a small price to pay for a lifetime of delicious breakfast options.

And what will be the best sandwich toaster in 2022? If you are interested in this subject subscribe us and share your opinion in a comment. Thank you!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.