We'd like to recommend you the best products! We may get a small share of the sale should you buy something through our recommendation links.

Best Pop Up Hot Dog Toasters – Top 5 Models in 2021

Best pop up hot dog toaster

Hot dogs are one of those gloriously uncomplicated meals that are quite easy to make. And in case you were having trouble picking the best pop up hot dog toaster from the marketplace, worry not because this shortlist of five of the best is here to make your selection process easier.

To come up with this comprehensive list, I spent hundreds of hours of testing different pop up hot dog toasters to see which ones would meet my criteria. Remember, the market is filled with mediocre models, all claiming to be the best of the best, so separating the chaff from the wheat was no easy task.

And after all that hassle, below is a short list of the best pop up hot dog toasters in the market place today.

Best Pop Up Hot Dog Toasters – Top 5 Models in 2021

  • While testing this tool, I realized it could make two perfectly toasted hot dogs at home in less than ten minutes. That is impressive. And if you’re the guy who is always on the move and on the market looking for the best pop up hot dog toaster that will save you lots of time in the morning, then this is your product.
  • The second feature that blew my mind was the 5 adjustable toaster settings on the appliance. These settings are in place to accommodate everyone’s taste in your family. Let us say your children love their hot dogs heavily toasted, but you love yours lightly toasted. In such a case all you need to do is use the different adjustable toaster settings on the appliance to give everyone what they want.
  • In this pop up hot dog toaster, you will also find slots for your hot dog buns and two other slots where you can place the sausages.
  • To make your cleaning process easier, Smart Planet included a removable crumb tray on this appliance to collect all the debris and bread pieces coming from your buns. Say no to a messy kitchen from today.
  • Another feature worth noting about the Smart Planet HDT‐1S Peanuts Snoopy Hot Dog Toaster is the fact it boasts a cool to touch exterior. This is in place to protect you just in case you accidentally touch the toaster while it’s operating.
  • Bnsure you do not touch in between the slots because they get hot!

Notable features:

  • Easy to clean, thanks to the removable crumb tray
  • Can make two hot dogs at the same time
  • Boasts multiple adjustable toaster settings
  • Includes a high lever that allows you to retrieve the hot dogs safely
  • It’s a 2 in 1 device
  • For those who have a big family or usually have a lot of friends coming over to their houses, this is the product for you. Unlike most products I tested while coming up with this list, Nostalgia RHDT800RETRORED Four Dogs & Buns Pop-Up Toaster can make four buns and four hot dogs at the same time.
  • And the result of each hot dog this appliance delivered was delicious just like with the “2 slot alternatives.” The bright minds behind this appliance were also wise enough to include a drip tray that allows easy cleaning.
  • I also liked the adjustable cooking timer included and the stop cooking button. The timer is in place to notify you when your meal is ready for consumption, whereas the stop cooking function allows you to stop and cut short the appliance’s toasting procedure.
  • The package you will receive after acquiring this gadget will also include mini tongs that allow you to easily remove the hot dogs. In between slots tends to get really hot, so the tongs will help you retrieve the meal without coming too close in a way that may harm you.
  • The pros and features that set this hot dog toaster apart do not stop there. This appliance can be acquired in two different colors, red and aqua. This can come in handy.
  • My best friend’s favorite color, for instance, is Aqua, and so when her birthday came around, I got the Aqua version of the Nostalgia Pop-Up Toaster for her.
  • So if you would like to acquire the product as a gift for a loved one, you have two different colors to choose from.

Notable features:

  • Can serve a bigger family
  • Toasts very fast
  • The package includes mini tongs
  • Boasts a drip tray that makes cleaning easy
  • Just like the Smart Planet pop up hot dog toaster we checked out earlier, Nostalgia HDT600COKE Coca-Cola Pop-Up Hot Dog Toaster boasts slots that can fit two buns as well as two sausages so you can make two perfect hot dogs with total efficiency and ease.
  • After seeing the exterior design of this tool, I decided it was a must inclusion in my kitchen space. It is durable, but ensure you maintain it carefully so it can keep serving you and your family members for years to come.
  • The high lift lever also came in handy to ensure users do not burn their fingers by touching that part between the slots as they try retrieving the toasted meals. Nostalgia HDT600COKE Coca-Cola Pop-Up Hot Dog Toaster comes with mini tongs as well to help you remove the hot dogs.
  • The drip tray included in the appliance is in place to ensure easy cleaning.
  • If you live alone or in a dorm at school, then this gadget is the perfect product for you.

Notable features:

  • Includes a drip tray that makes cleaning easy
  • Has a stop cooking button that allows you to stop the toasting procedure whenever you wish
  • Great for small families or someone who lives alone
  • Comes with mini tongs that help remove hot dogs
  • Manufactured by Nostalgia, a reputable brand
  • Enjoy a perfect toasted hot dog with the Americana By Elite ECT-542BL Retro Pop-Up Hot Dog Toaster. With its gorgeous brushed stainless steel finish, this conventional, yet aesthetic toaster is the perfect addition to any modern kitchen.
  • The two, extra wide slots included on the appliance can accommodate thick bread slices or buns and for easy removal, mini tongs are included in the package to help you out with the hot dogs and buns. The five adjustable shade settings will allow you to toast each hot dog to your own liking.

Notable features:

  • Aesthetic and will look good on any kitchen counter
  • Easy to use and store
  • Easy and fast cleanup thanks to the removable crumb tray
  • Versatile
  • Compact to save on space
  • Measuring 9” x 5” x 8.2”, Nostalgia HDT600COKE Limited Edition Coca-Cola Pop-Up Hot Dog Toaster is a compact pop up hot dog toaster retailing with an aesthetic exterior that will blend in with any interior décor.
  • Another impressive fact about this hot dog toaster that it retails with a 90-day warranty. This is essential. The second pop up hot dog toaster I acquired had a malfunction two months after getting it, and since it was still covered by the warranty, I simply took it back, and the company fixed it for me.
  • 90 days does not seem a lot when you compare it to most warranties you have come across, but trust me, in the realm of pop up hot dog toasters, it is a fair duration.
  • You will also love the quick cleaning drain trays as well as mini tongs included in the package. If you’re anything like me, cleaning is one of your most boring activities, so acquiring a pop up hot dog toaster that is easy to clean should be a must consideration for you.
  • To operate it, all you need to do is place the 2 hot dogs and 2 buns into their respective compartments, adjust the timing knob as required, and then press the lever down to operate the tool. Simple, right?

Notable features:

  • Looks good
  • Compact
  • Easy to operate
  • Delivered consistent results
  • Easy to clean
  • Perfect for people who live alone


If you pick one of the pop up hot dog toasters from this enumeration above, you can rest assured your experience of making hot dogs will never be the same again. I tested all five products myself, so I root for their ability to deliver the best results.

My favorite toaster, after extensive research was the Nostalgia HDT600COKE Coca-Cola Pop-Up Hot Dog Toaster. This pop up hot dog toaster included a drip tray, which made cleaning extremely easy and the hot dog cage was removable as well.

And what will be the best hot dog pop up toaster in 2022? If you are interested in this subject subscribe us and share your opinion in a comment. Thank you!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.