We'd like to recommend you the best products! We may get a small share of the sale should you buy something through our recommendation links.

The Best Pizza Toasters Recommended by Experts in Present-day

Best pizza toaster

In order to come up with this post, I endured weeks of carb loading on cupcakes, baked potatoes, frozen pizzas, and garlic bread. I even spent more than 40 hours baking, broiling, toasting, and researching to ascertain which products qualified as the best pizza toasters.

If you’re a pizza lover and would like to avail a more authentic taste for your food, then it is time to pick one product from this enumeration I crafted for you. All products featured here are effective and durable.

Better yet, some of them are multifunctional conventional ovens that retail with trays, so not only pizza can be made with them.

Without further delay, let us skip to the main section of the post and look at the 5 best pizza toasters that you can choose from.

The Top 5 Pizza Toaster available today

Toaster NameWeightTemp. ControlDimensionsSlicesPrice
Hamilton Beach Countertop Toaster Oven11.4 lbsYes15.2x18.7x9.4 in6 Check Price
Toshiba Mechanical oven, Black Stainless Steel14.89 lbsYes19x10.8x15.6 in6 Check Price
Hamilton Beach, Red Pizza Maker6.36 lbsYes15.9x13.4x7.1 in4 Check Price
Presto Pizzazz Plus Rotating Oven8 lbsYes15.8x14.5x10.3 in4 Check Price
Maxi-Matic Retro Pizza Toaster, Blue 13.23 lbsYes19.1x16.3x12.8 in6 Check Price
  • If the ability to retrieve hot food from your toaster and easiness of cleaning are important features to you, then the Hamilton Beach Countertop Toaster Oven is the best choice. The ability to take out hot food will come in handy, particularly if your kids will be using the appliance to prepare waffles, morning toasts, or after school snacks.
  • The toaster’s exclusive roll top door also makes quite easy access to your toasted meals compared to conventional toaster models whose doors had to be pulled outward and down to open.
  • This toaster oven design also needs less counter space in your kitchen, so if you’re trying to save on space, this will suit you. Hamilton Beach Countertop Toaster Oven also helps keeping its door free of cheese gooey messes and the kitchen counter free from crumbs.
  • And even though this model is quite smaller than most, with dimensions of 9.4”x18.7”x15.2”, it is spacious enough to fit a 9”x11” baking pan, make toast for up to six individuals and even heat a 12” frozen pizza.
  • A baking pan, rack and removable crumb tray also comes with the toaster oven, which has bake, broil and toast functions to. prepare different kinds of meals.

Notable features:

  • Easy access to food
  • Compact and doesn’t consume kitchen space
  • Comes with all functions including toast, broil, and the baking option
  • Includes a 30-minute timer with auto shut-off
  • Easy to clean
  • Can prepare a variety of dishes
  • With its impressive performance, a generous set of quality bake ware, large interior, multitude features, unique intelligent heating elements, and high-end design, you can easily use this Hamilton Beach Countertop Toaster Oven in addition or in place of your conventional oven.
  • It’s easy to use interface and beautiful modern look with nine customizable functionalities also made me ensure to include it in this enumeration. The toaster can also deliver the most efficient baking, toasting, and broiling, while its cool-touch handle makes it safe for you to open the door and check or remove the food.

Notable features:

  • Sturdy and durable
  • Comes with a timer for monitoring
  • Non-stick interior and stainless-steel exterior
  • Cooks very fast
  • Removable crumb tray
  • Innovative Accu-Timer technology
  • Convection fan, which circulate hot air throughout the oven
  • The Hamilton Beach 31700 is an easy to use pizza maker with the ability to rotate. This rotating feature ensures even cooking. The appliance also boasts a viewing window that allows you to check the meals cooking progress constantly.
  • Cooking with this toaster is also easy as it boasts the option to adjust the level of heat when it is on and the oven will never need any preheating. It also comes with an inbuilt feature that shuts off the device automatically after 30 minutes.
  • When you or your family crave pizza, there’s no need to order out. You can save money by preparing your own pizza. This product can cook a 12” pizza 40% faster than a regular oven and saves energy too.

Notable features:

  • Can cook other foods such as cookies, vegetables, and quesadillas
  • Cooks faster
  • Built-in timer
  • Boasts a heating system both on top and at the bottom
  • Aesthetic
  • The Presto 03430 is a countertop pizza toaster that can bake a pizza in half the time that would be needed by a conventional kitchen oven. Given the tool starts cooking your meals the moment you plug it in, you’ll never need to worry about preheating.
  • The rotating tray assure even baking and the top and bottom heating elements bake foods from both sides. Heating elements are separately controlled, allowing you to select top, bottom or both for the perfect result.
  • The tool also retails with a cooking timer that you can also use while reheating your food products. The appliance will automatically turn off once it is done. You will love this appliance’s heating capabilities.

Notable features:

  • Includes a timer
  • Easy to clean due to removable non-stick pan
  • Has heating elements on both the top and the bottom side
  • Saves 60% energy compared to traditional ovens
  • Saves on space
  • This compact and extremely efficient toaster model impressed me with its precise and even browning to different levels of darkness as well as its quick cooking times. The tool quickly reach the adjusted temperature and it won’t keep you waiting.
  • We also love its door and body design. Retrieving food from this appliance is also extremely easy, so you won’t need to worry about burning your fingers or your kids getting in any sort of danger as they try to use the appliance.
  • You can bake, broil and reheat your food with this gadget, which can fit a 12” pizza or 6 slices of bread. It also has an adjustable timer and temperature control up to 480 F.
  • Accessories included in this appliance are an aesthetic square baking tray that is perfect for pizza as well as a removable crumb tray and a wire rack. The removable tray makes the appliance easy to clean.

Notable features:

  • Easy access to ready meals
  • Easy to clean
  • Can cook different sorts of foods
  • Won’t take up too much space in your kitchen
  • Heats up and cooks pretty quickly


The best pizza toaster could be an indispensable breakfast fixer, dinner prep helper, and even a snack maker. And I hope my enumeration has helped you pick the best one for you and your family needs. But in case you still need help picking one from the five products above, I urge you to try out the Hamilton Beach Countertop Toaster Oven.

This toaster has curved design, a door that pushes upwards, and grey color that distinguish it from the competitors. Better yet, the appliance performed well in baked potatoes, frozen pizza, garlic bread, cupcakes, and even toast tests. Its simplicity won’t let you down either.

And what will be the best pizza toaster next year? If you are interested in this subject subscribe us and share your opinion in a comment. Thank you!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.