We'd like to recommend you the best products! We may get a small share of the sale should you buy something through our recommendation links.

The 5 Safest Toaster Ovens in 2021

Best safest toaster oven

Believe it or not, the best toaster ovens have come a very long way since their introduction as bagel-making machines. Most have bigger capacities that allow you to prepare meals that can satisfy your entire family and others have been fitted with futuristic features that can improve your flexibility in the kitchen.

That said, today we’re going to look at the safest toaster ovens that can deliver perfectly in the cooking department. If you have children running around your kitchen while preparing a meal, then safety is a must-have – and one of the main safety features is a cool to the touch exterior surface.

For those who are not accustomed to this feature, a cool to the touch exterior means that regardless of how long the toaster oven will be in operation, it’s exterior surface won’t get overheated. This ensures that anyone who comes into contact with the appliance during operations will not sustain any burn injuries.

In addition to that, the cool to the touch exterior makes sure hot air does not escape from inside the toaster oven, which in turn ensures quick and even cooking.

Without wasting any more of your time, let us skip to the main section of the post and look at the safest toaster ovens money can buy today.

The Top 5 Best Safest Toaster Ovens in 2021

Toaster Oven NameWeightTimerDimensionsSlicePrice
Oster Toaster Oven20.3 lbsYes16.3 x 19.7 x 11.3 in4 Check Price
Countertop Convection Toaster Oven15.76 lbsYes22.8 x 13.4 x 15.5 in4 Check Price
Hamilton Beach Countertop Toaster Oven14.12 lbsYes15 x 18.5 x 9.5 in6 Check Price
Toaster Oven 4 Slice2.2 lbsYes17 x 14 x 11 in4 Check Price
Rotisserie Countertop Toaster Oven17.38 lbsYes20 x 15.2 x 12.1 in6 Check Price
  • If you’ve been following my posts for a while, then you know that I love starting all my reviews on a high note. With that in mind, the first appliance in our enumeration is from one of the most reputable brands in the realm of kitchen appliances.
  • In addition, this Oster Toaster Oven boasts an extra-large interior that can easily serve a small party without a hassle (which is evident from its image above.) If you’re willing to sacrifice some space that can accommodate this masterpiece, then you’re in luck. It also comes with digital settings to defrost, toast, broil, bake, convection bake, warm and pizzas. Couple that with its high-quality heating elements and you have one of the most reliable toaster ovens.

Notable features:

  • Delivers evenly cooked meals
  • Very spacious interior
  • Easy to clean
  • Comes with a baking pan and removable crumb tray
  • Durable, sturdy and powerful

Safest Toaster Oven #2:

  • If you’re looking for the simplest toaster oven that can still be one of the best high-end toaster ovens that is a run for their money, then this BLACK+DECKER CTO6335S could be what you’re looking for.
  • The appliance’s design allows it to fit in any small space on your kitchen counter and it has also been fitted with a wide array of settings to improve your flexibility in the cooking department. These settings include bagel, toast, broil, bake, convection bake, frozen snacks, potato, pizza, and cookies.
  • If you are not familiar with the bagel setting, it will allow you to toast only the cut side of your slices.

Notable features:

  • Compact to save on space
  • Easy to use and clean
  • Lightweight and portable
  • The feet are anti-skid
  • Very durable

Safest Toaster Oven #3:

  • This review would be incomplete without a masterpiece from Hamilton Beach. This company has been around for more than a century, and if that proves anything, it’s that they are in tune with what their customers require.
  • But what sets Hamilton Beach 31123D Toaster Oven apart. Well, first, this appliance retails with a door that opens up and out of the way to prevent messy spills and drips. It also has a spacious interior, 2 rack positions, four different settings, and it is easy to use even for total beginners.

Notable features:

  • Wil blend in with any kitchen interior décor
  • Easy to use
  • Easy to clean
  • Delivers evenly cooked meals
  • Has a cord storage underneath

Safest Toaster Oven #4:

  • The next masterpiece in our enumeration is the Mueller Austria Toaster Oven. At first glance, I noticed that this appliance is not from the most reputable toaster oven brand. But I also noticed its aesthetic nature, durable design, and a long list of features it comes with.
  • So, I decided to place an order anyway and give it a try to see if it could deliver everything it advertises. When the package arrived from Amazon, the first thing I tested was its consistency. I used it to toast 10 different meals back to back without letting the appliance rest, and needless to say, the last meal to go into the appliance came out just as perfectly cooked as the first one. While testing its consistency, I also noticed several things including its inbuilt convection design and a 30-minute timer.
  • Unlike most other convection toaster ovens, Mueller Austria Toaster Oven does not come with an inbuilt fan to blow hot air around inside the appliance. instead, its interior has a naturally built in a manner that’ll allow it to move hot air around just as fine as other convection toaster ovens.
  • The built-in timer will automatically switch off the appliance when the timer runs out. Also, if you’re preparing a meal you’ve never prepared before, I suggest you start with a lower time. This way, if the meal comes out and it’s not sufficiently cooked, then you can simply put it back and toast it some more. If you set a higher time, however, and the food comes out overcooked, there won’t be anything you can do to correct that.
  • The toaster oven also retails with a spacious interior and a removable crumb tray. I could effortlessly fit in four artisan bread slices and a 9” pizza inside the appliance. The removable crumb tray, for those who don’t know what it does, will collect every dirt and crumbs that break off of your cooked meals. This makes the appliance easy to clean since all you’ll have to do is take out the crumb tray, wipe it off using a damp cloth, and put it back inside the appliance.
  • For thorough cleaning, check out this guide on how to clean the interior of a toaster oven. The guide will help you ensure your oven is looking great at all times.

Notable features:

  • Boasts a durable and sturdy build
  • Easy to use and clean
  • Its feet are anti-skid
  • Retails with an interior light that’ll allow you to see what is going on inside the appliance
  • Has been fitted with the bake, broil, toast, and keep warm functions
  • Its cord storage is long enough
  • Has an inbuilt convection design
  • Delivers delicious and evenly cooked meals
  • The last, but by no means the least safest toaster oven in this review is the Emerson Convection & Rotisserie Countertop Toaster Oven. Just like its name suggests, this work of art easily qualifies as the best rotisserie oven too in the market today.
  • As you can see from the image above, the appliance boasts a futuristic design and a perfect color combination. I tested it in multiple kitchens with different interior decors and it blended in seamlessly with all of them.
  • It has also been fitted with the keep warm, toast, broil, and bake settings to improve its flexibility in your kitchen.

Notable features:

  • Has an aesthetic design
  • Has a highly reliable rotisserie function
  • Comes with a sensor touch digital control panel
  • Very versatile
  • Easy to use and clean


I hope my review has helped you open your eyes and allowed you to pick the next safest toaster oven that can meet your home’s needs and requirements.

If you’re stuck between two appliances and having a hard time making a final, educated decision, allow me to jump in and make a suggestion. If I were to pick from the list above, I would pick the Mueller Austria Toaster Oven as the safest toaster oven in the market today. This masterpiece will not only protect everyone in your household, but it will also cook quickly, it is energy efficient, versatile, and easy to clean. Give it a try and let me know what you think.

And what will be the best safest toaster oven in 2022? If you are interested in this subject subscribe us and share your opinion in a comment. Thank you!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.