The 6 Best Pizza Toaster Ovens in 2021

All pizza lovers I’ve ever come across have one thing in common, they understand the importance of having the best pizza toaster oven at home. Come on, think about it: these appliances allow you to make fresh, delicious pizza with your favorite toppings on it at any time of the day. If that doesn’t sound like a blissful dream to you, I don’t know what will.

Anyway, to help make this dream come true for you, I have compiled an ultimate list of the most reputable, popular toaster oven models you can pick today. These units are durable, consistent with their results, powerful, sturdy, and will be easy to use even for total beginners.

Without wasting any more of your time, let’s skip to the main section of the post and look at the best pizza toaster ovens money can buy today.

Oster TSSTTVPZDS Toaster Oven

• Oster TSSTTVPZDS Oven’s unique selling proposition will be obvious to you straight out of the box. As you can see in the product’s image above, the unit retails with a dedicated pizza drawer that can also double up as a great place to prepare quesadillas and bruschetta. This also boosts the versatility of the appliance as you can use the drawer and the main oven part at the same time to prepare two different meals.
• What’s more? To ensure that the two different cooking areas perform exceptionally, it has also been fitted with a convection cooking setting. This implies that unlike regular toaster ovens, this one comes with an inbuilt fan that will blow hot air around inside the oven for fast cooking and even browning.
• That said, as I always say, not all meals should be cooked the same way using a high heat intensity and not all of them should be cooked using the convection setting. Some foods need to be cooked slowly and under a low heat intensity for tastier results.
• With that in mind, this guide on how to bake a cake using a toaster oven will show you the different levels you’re supposed to engage the convection setting.
• If you purchase this appliance through Amazon, you’ll also find different accessories inside the package. These include a baking rack and a baking pan double as a broiling pan when assembled. All of them are there to improve your flexibility during cooking sessions.

Notable features:

• Has a sturdy design
• Durable
• Easy to use even for beginners
• Fitted with a convection setting
• Boasts a 60-minute timer, bell signal, and an auto shut off feature
• Has a separate pizza drawer
• Very versatile
• Consistent with its results

Black & Decker Pizza Toaster Oven

• The sad reality of owning a toaster oven is the fact it’ll spend more than 90 percent of its life seated idly on your kitchen counter. But still, you can take advantage of this and invest in a tool that complements your interior decor, and that’s why I always try my best to include at least one of the best aesthetic toaster ovens in my reviews.
• When this masterpiece from Black & Decker arrived from Amazon, I took it through a series of tests, after which I placed it on my kitchen counter. It’s been three weeks now and everyone who has walked into the space has had something to say about the unit’s sleek design.
• Black & Decker Pizza Toaster Oven didn’t disappoint in the toasting department either. Its spacious interior could fit a 12” family-sized pizza and its heating element allowed it to cook frozen snacks and pizza slices to perfection.
• Use the timer and temperature adjustment knob on the right side of the appliance to set a combo that will ensure great results. And when the time you’ve set on the timer runs out, the appliance will automatically switch off, so your meal doesn’t get overcooked.

Notable features:

• Has a unique design
• Easy to use and clean
• The power cord is sufficiently long
• The exterior surface remains cool to the touch
• The feet are anti-skid on wet surfaces
• Retails from a reputable brand

Hamilton Beach 31331D Toaster Oven

• This guide on the best pizza toaster ovens would be incomplete without at least one masterpiece from one of the most reputable kitchen appliances brands out there. Founded in 1910 by Frederick J. Osius, Hamilton Beach is an American kitchen appliances brand that offers drink mixers, blenders, toaster ovens, and other professional kitchen equipment for businesses around the world.
• For the decades the company has been in existence, it has become best known for its ability to amalgamate retro designs and futuristic features in the same appliance, and this Hamilton Beach 31331D Oven is no different.
• As you can see from its image above, this unit looks like something straight out of the 50s, but don’t let that fool you into thinking that it doesn’t deliver in the toasting department. For starters, the unit has been fitted with a convection technology (which use and benefit I explained above.) It has also been fitted with heating elements of the highest quality. While reviewing the product online, I even saw the manufacturing brand pointing out that once you set the time and temperature, the appliance will automatically adjust the heat intensity, so the appliance doesn’t end up burning your food.
• During my test sessions, the appliance also delivered perfectly toasted slices in less than three minutes. That’s as fast as some of the fastest toaster ovens I’ve ever had the pleasure of testing.
• Another feature worth noting is the two rack positions. These improve the tool’s flexibility because it gives you the freedom to either place your food closer to the heating elements or further from them. Better yet, while preparing some meals like cookies, you can feel free to use the two rack positions at the same time, thanks to the convection setting that will ensure the hot air reaches both rack positions equally.

Notable features:

• Designed for easy access
• Has a sufficiently spacious interior
• Very versatile
• Fitted with a convection technology for fast and even cooking
• The feet are anti-skid even on wet surfaces
• Offers two rack positions
• Easy to use and clean

Oster French Door Toaster Oven

• Just like the first product in this enumeration, the fourth one is also from Oster, which shows you that the brand has gone above and beyond to ensure that the products they sell their customers are of the highest quality.
• And while this unit doesn’t retail with a dedicated pizza drawer like its first counterpart, it is just as sturdy and durable as that one. I have three friends who own restaurants and use this masterpiece. And when I reached out to them to ask whether they would recommend it to their loved ones, they all pointed out that their models have never run into any issues in the past.
• After all, if the unit can qualify as one of the best restaurant toaster ovens, what makes you think that the needs of your home will slow it down?
• What’s more? Just like the product we just looked at (and as you can see from the product’s image above), Oster French Door Toaster Oven also retails with 2 rack positions that you can use at once to save time.
• Another feature of the appliance worth noting is its ease of cleaning. Inside the package you will receive from Amazon, you will find several accessories, including a durable baking pan, 2 racks, and a removable crumb tray. The crumb tray is the one that’ll make your cleaning sessions easier. This part of the tool will collect all the dirt and debris that fall off of your cooked meals. And to clean it, all you ought to do is take it out, empty its contents into a bin, and wipe it off using a damp cloth. For the thorough, once a month cleaning session, here is a guide on how to clean the interior of your toaster oven.

Notable features:

• Fitted with a 90-minute timer and auto shut off feature
• Accessories included to improve the tool’s flexibility
• Boasts a convection technology
• Retails from a reputable brand
• Consistent with its results
• Easy to clean
• Will compliment any kitchen interior décor
• Durable and sturdy

COSORI Toaster Oven

• Not only does this masterpiece retail from one of the most reputable toaster oven brands, but it’s also arguably the most versatile model in today’s enumeration. It has been fitted with 12 different cooking functions, including ferment, cookies, broil, bake, bagel, toast, air fry, roast, pizza, dehydrate, warm and rotisserie.
• I don’t know about you, but those are more than enough to handle the needs of my family.
• What’s more? Couple all those settings with the access to 100 Original Recipes that the manufacturing company offers you and you have one of the most reliable toaster ovens. The recipes will come in handy especially if you’re new to cooking and cannot come up with recipes of your own. If you feel like it, you can also tweak the recipes Cosori is offering you and make them your own overtime.
• COSORI Toaster Oven also retails with a smart control that allows you to connect the toaster oven to your phone and adjust the timer and temperature from there. You can also use your phone to monitor the process, control the convection fan, switch on/off the oven light, choose a recipe, and receive notifications about your food’s cooking progress. If that doesn’t make the unit one of the best smart toaster ovens, I don’t know what will.
• Accessories you will find in the package include a rotisserie handle, rotisserie shaft, one removable crumb tray, a food tray, a fry basket, an original recipe book, and a wire rack.

Notable features:

• Very powerful
• Fitted with many smart control settings
• The manufacturing company gives you access to 100 recipes
• Very versatile
• Different accessories included in the package
• Easy to use and clean
• Has a large interior capacity

Carejoy Toaster Oven

• How could we create a guide on the best pizza toaster oven and not include at least one unit with the most unique design? With this stroke of genius on your kitchen countertop, you can rest assured it will leave anyone who walks in there in awe.
• That said, looks aren’t the only thing this bad boy has to offer. For starters, the unit has been fitted with 2000 watts of power that will allow it to handle anything your home throws in it. This also hands down puts it on the same level as the most powerful toaster ovens.
• Carejoy Toaster Oven also boasts a see-through glass and an interior lighting that makes your food visible during cooking sessions. This will come in handy when preparing a meal, you’ve never prepared before, because if you see through the glass door that the food has been readily cooked but the timer hasn’t run out yet, you can simply go ahead and switch off the toaster and retrieve your meal.

Notable features:

• Has a unique design
• Easy to use and clean
• Very powerful
• Versatile
• Reliable enough to handle the needs of a restaurant
• Has a cool to the touch exterior

There you have it! My exhaustive and detailed guide on the best pizza toaster ovens. Given the time I dedicated to testing all the units in the enumeration, I’m confident that the list has at least one product that can meet anyone’s pizza-related needs and requirements.

With that in mind, if you have found a unit you think aligns with your needs, I urge you to go ahead and place an order while stock lasts. But if you like more than one appliance and are having a hard time making a final, educated decision, allow me to chip in and help you out.

If I were to pick a product from the list above, I’d pick the Oster French Door Toaster Oven as my favorite. Like you, I’m a cooking aficionado and this appliance’s versatility and two rack positions awards me more freedom when it comes to meals I can prepare.

And what will be the best pizza toaster oven in 2022? If you are interested in this subject subscribe us and share your opinion in a comment. Thank you!