We'd like to recommend you the best products! We may get a small share of the sale should you buy something through our recommendation links.

The 7 Best Hamilton Beach Toaster Ovens in 2021 1

Best Hamilton Beach toaster oven

If you’ve checked out my guide on how to pick the best toaster oven, then you remember that one of the tips I mentioned beginners should always follow is breaking down the choices according to their manufacturing brands and only pick from the most reputable ones. I suggest this because, unlike lesser-known brands, huge and renowned brands have a reputation to protect, so they will go above and beyond to ensure that all the products they release can perform as advertised.

With that in mind, I decided to go out there myself and created a shortlist of the best toaster oven models from arguably the best toaster ovens brand available today. Founded in 1910 by Frederick J. Osius, Hamilton Beach Holding Company is an American designer, distributor, and marketer of commercial restaurant equipment and home appliances mainly marketed in the United States.

Over the century the company has been in existence, it has become best known for its ability to combine retro designs and futuristic features in all their products, and that’s exactly what all these 7 products in this guide deliver.

Another thing I ought to mention. Even though the company is known to deliver as expected, I still had to do some research and pick the best of the best from the company – only those that are worth the buck. Features I looked at during my review and test sessions include:

  • Aesthetics
  • Safety features
  • Consistency
  • Interior capacity
  • Ease of cleaning
  • Ease of use
  • Durability and sturdiness
  • And much more.

Only products that passed all the areas above with flying colors made it into this final list. Without wasting any more of your time, let’s skip to the main section of the content and look at the 7 best Hamilton Beach toaster ovens money can buy today.

The Top 7 Best Hamilton Beach Toaster Ovens in 2021

Toaster Oven NameWeightTimerDimensionsSlicePrice
6-Slice Countertop Toaster Oven11.4 lbsYes15.24 x 18.74 x 9.41 in6 Check Price
Digital Countertop Toaster Oven19.8 lbsYes15.5 x 20 x 12 in4 Check Price
2-in-1 Countertop Oven10.9 lbsYes12.05 x 17.8 x 10.24 in4 Check Price
Easy Reach Toaster Oven8.22 lbsYes11.93 x 16.12 x 8.97 in2 Check Price
Digital Display Toaster Oven17.15 lbsYes11.97 x 18.82 x 14.92 in2 Check Price
Toaster Oven & Pizza Maker7.33 lbsYes14.96 x 11.5 x 8.7 in4 Check Price
Convection Countertop Toaster Oven21 lbsYes13.11 x 20.62 x 16.54 in4 Check Price

Hamilton Beach Toaster Oven #1:

  • Straight out of the box, the first thing that caught my eye about this masterpiece was its roll-top door. This implies that unlike most toaster oven models, Hamilton Beach 31127D Toaster Oven’s door will open up and out of the way to ensure you do not smear any foodstuff on it while retrieving your meals. The fact that the door will always be clean will not only leave the appliance looking elegant but also significantly reduce your work during cleaning sessions.
  • Speaking of its ease of cleaning, it has been fitted with a removable crumb tray that will be included in the package you will receive from Amazon. For those of you who are new to these appliances and do not know what a removable crumb tray does, it’s simply the part of the tool responsible for collecting all the dirt and debris that fall off of your meals. To clean the crumb tray, all you ought to do is take it out, empty its contents into a sink or bin, and wipe it off using a clean, damp cloth. That said, from time to time, you will need to thoroughly clean the appliance, and lucky for you, these cleaning sessions won’t be a hassle either because the interior has been coated with a non-stick material.
  • Here is a detailed guide on how to clean the interior of your toaster oven.
  • As you can tell from the product’s image above, the appliance easily qualifies as one of the best retro toaster ovens out there. The unit looks like something straight out of the ’50s but will perform like something from the future.

Notable features

  • The exterior surface remains cool to the touch during operations
  • Easy to use and clean
  • Has a spacious interior
  • Retails from a reputable brand
  • Feet are anti-skid even on wet surfaces
  • Its knobs are easy to contour
  • Just from its name, you can tell exactly what this masterpiece is capable of. It’s without a doubt one of the best convection toaster ovens you can invest in nowadays, and for good reason. During my research sessions, I came across hundreds of people who pointed out that they have been using this exact model in their restaurants and that it was perfect for rush hour periods. And as I always say, if the product can easily handle the needs of a restaurant, then you can rest assured your home’s needs won’t stress it in the slightest.
  • Having said that, other than its ability to deliver and reliability, what else has this HAMILTON BEACH PROFESSIONAL Convection 31240 Toaster Oven has got to deliver? Well, first and foremost, the unit has been designed using stainless steel of the highest quality. This not only ensures that the unit will keep serving your family for years to come, but it also improves its sturdiness. After I was done testing the unit, my daughter knocked it down around four times, but none of them did anything that slows down the unit’s ability to deliver.
  • Another feature of the appliance worth noting is the fact it has been backed by a 3-year limited warranty. If that doesn’t prove that the company has faith in the product they are selling you, then I do not know what does. Add to that the digital display the unit has been fitted with, and you will understand why it also qualifies as one of the best reliable toaster ovens out there today. The digital display will allow you to track the oven’s temperature and pick from seven different cooking settings fitted in the appliance. These settings include reheat, keep warm, broil, bake, convection, toast, and bagel.

Notable features

  • Backed by a 3-year limited warranty
  • Has an integrated temperature probe
  • Fitted with 7 versatile settings
  • Boasts a spacious interior capacity
  • Easy to use and clean
  • Can handle the needs of a restaurant
  • The power cord is sufficiently long

Hamilton Beach Toaster Oven #3:

  • If you have a small kitchen and are scouring the internet looking for the best Hamilton beach toaster oven that also doubles up as one of the best versatile toaster ovens, then allow me to introduce you the Hamilton Beach 31156 Toaster Oven.
  • As you can tell from the product’s image above, it also retails with a toasting slot at the top. If you’re a fan of toasties as well, then this means that you won’t need to invest in a separate two-slice toaster, something that would have consumed precious space in your kitchen. Do not let the fact that the slot has been added to a toaster oven fool you into thinking that it cannot deliver as well as some of the best regular toasters out there. I tested it myself and to say that it delivered some of the most delicious bagels would be an understatement. Both slices came out brown and crunchy on the outside, but soft and warm on the inside. To adjust between the oven and toast setting, use the slide placed on the top right corner of the appliance.
  • What about the unit’s aesthetics? Well, it retails in three different colors, also making it one of the best gift options if you have a loved one’s party or wedding coming up. The three colors (stainless steel, red, and black) will improve your chances of acquiring it in a shade that matches the recipient’s favorite color. If you will be getting the appliance for yourself, this variation in shades will also ensure that you pick the unit in a color that most complements your kitchen interior décor.
  • Let’s touch on portability. When the time came to test the appliance, my favorite show had just come on TV and I didn’t really feel like leaving it to go into the kitchen to test the toaster oven. So, what did I do? I simply brought the unit into my living room and tested it from there – and this wasn’t a hassle thanks to the toaster oven’s lightweight nature (10.9 pounds) and compact design (item dimensions – 10.24 x 17.8 x 12.05 inches)

Notable features:

  • Retails from one of the most reputable brands
  • You can choose from three different colors
  • Feet are anti-skid on wet surfaces
  • Has a retro design
  • Has a slot fit on the top
  • The exterior surface remains cool to the touch during operations
  • Easy to clean and use

Hamilton Beach Toaster Oven #4:

  • Are you all about designs and are looking for a great Hamilton beach model that also qualifies as one of the best unique toaster ovens? If yes, then this Hamilton Beach 31337D Toaster Oven could be exactly what you are looking for.
  • Just like the first product we looked at in this review, this one also boasts a roll-top door that will move up and out of the way so you can safely and easily access your meal before and after cooking. Since the door is moving up and out of the way, you can rest assured that messy drips and spills will be avoided.
  • In regard to the interior space, I know it looks small from the image above, but that couldn’t be further from the truth in actuality. During my test sessions, it could easily fit up to 4 slices of artisan bread or a 9” pizza. I do not know about you, but that was more than sufficient to handle the needs of my family.
  • While checking out what previous customers had to say on online forums, lots of cooking enthusiasts kept pointing out the unit’s durability. Two of them claimed that they had been using their unit for more than eight years and it had never run into any issues. So, if you’re looking for a durable unit that is assured to keep serving your family for years to come, it is still the unit for you.

Notable features:

  • Boasts a stainless-steel build
  • Easy to use and clean
  • The knobs are easy to contour
  • The unit’s roll-top door opens up and out of the way
  • The feet are anti-skid even on wet surfaces
  • The heating elements are of the highest quality

Hamilton Beach Toaster Oven #5:

  • This review would be incomplete if I didn’t include this masterpiece from Hamilton Beach. I first came across this unit while reviewing appliances for a guide I was working on. The guide’s title was “The 5 best commercial toaster ovens” and this masterpiece was one of the units I tested. Anyway, even though the appliance did not make it into that shortlist, its performance did leave me in awe, and I promised myself that I would always give it a chance when creating reviews where I thought it would fit. With that in mind, let’s get into it and look at the different features that will make you wish you had invested in this masterpiece years earlier.
  • First and foremost, this Hamilton Beach toaster oven retails with everything you might need to start cooking right out of the box. Accessories you will find inside the package you will receive from Amazon include a removable crumb tray, rotisserie accessories, a broil rack, and a baking pan. As noted earlier, the removable crumb tray will ensure it easily qualifies as one of the easiest to clean toaster ovens.
  • Second, the appliance has been fitted with one of the most reliable convection settings. For those who are new to toaster ovens and do not know what this feature does, it simply implies that the unit has been fitted with a fan that will blow hot air around inside the appliance for fast, and even cooking. The manufacturer claims that convection setting will allow the unit to cook meals 40 percent faster than regular toaster ovens, and after taking it through a series of test sessions, I have to agree that the claim isn’t a lie.
  • Another thing that left me in awe about this unit was its 6 versatile cooking settings, including a rotisserie, pizza, broil, bake, toast, and convection. I tested all of them myself and they performed as advertised. What’s more? Couple these versatile cooking settings with the fact that the unit boasts an LED display, and you’ll understand why some people refer to it as one of the best easy-to-use toaster ovens.

Notable features:

  • Accessories have been included in the package
  • Boasts easy to use digital controls
  • Fitted with 6 versatile cooking settings
  • The convection setting will blow hot air around inside the unit equally
  • Durable and sturdy
  • The unit is consistent with its results
  • Easy to use even for total beginners

Hamilton Beach Toaster Oven #6:

  • Around a decade ago, I had invested in a toaster oven that delivered some of the most delicious pizza slices and cakes. I genuinely believed that I had finally settled on a unit that would handle the needs of my home for years to come – until a not so scary tragedy struck.
  • One day while baking using the unit, my husband accidentally touched the appliance’s exterior surface and sustained some of the most excruciating burn injuries. With that scare in mind, I got rid of the unit and promised myself that I’d never ever again invest in a cooking appliance which exterior isn’t cool to the touch– and that is exactly what inspired me to include this masterpiece in this guide. Now, to help you better understand the unit’s cool to the touch nature, we ought to look at the addition that gives it this ability.
  • The unit has been perfectly insulated to ensure that the hot air inside the oven does not reach the outer surface. As you may have noted, this not only keeps the exterior cool to the touch but also means that the trapped air inside will allow the unit to cook faster than most standard toaster ovens. Its product description section on Amazon even does state that it uses 75 percent less energy and it is 28 percent faster than typical kitchen ovens when it comes to preheat frozen foods.
  • Hamilton Beach 31401 Toaster Oven’s review would be incomplete if we didn’t mention its timer and auto shut-off feature. The unit has been fitted with a 30-minute timer and a temperature adjustment knob that run’s up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit. Depending on the meal you are cooking, you’ll need to adjust the two settings into a combination that ensures perfect results. What’s more? After setting the timer and temperature, it will start cooking and if the timer runs out but you’re too far from the appliance to retrieve the meal, the unit will automatically shut off to avoid overcooking. The appliance will also let out a notification bell to notify you. The bell will be loud, so if you’re anywhere within your home, you can rest assured that you will hear it.

Notable features:

  • Uses up to 75 percent less energy and it is 28 percent faster
  • Fitted with a ready bell signal and auto shut off feature
  • Retails with a 30-minute timer and a temperature adjustment knob
  • The stainless-steel exterior will ensure durability and sturdiness
  • The classic design will look cool on any kitchen interior
  • Compact to save on kitchen counter space

Hamilton Beach Toaster Oven #7:

  • The last, but by no means the least, Hamilton Beach toaster oven in today’s ultimate guide is the Hamilton Beach 31107D. The first thing that I tested on this appliance after the package arrived from Amazon was its consistency. To do that, I went out, acquired 45 loaves of bread, and decided to toast all the slices back-to-back without letting it rest. What were the results? Well, to say that the unit’s performance exceeded my expectations would be an understatement because the last slice to go in came out just as perfectly and evenly toasted as the first one to go in. The unit also delivered the slices in less than two minutes, making it one of the fastest toaster ovens. So, if you are tired of leaving your home in a hurry and getting to school or work late because your meal took too long to prepare, this is the toaster oven that will solve all your worries.
  • As you can tell from the product image above, it boasts two different rack positions. This means that depending on the meal you are preparing, you can either use the top rack to place your meal close to the heating elements or use the bottom rack to place your meal a bit far from the heating elements. If you are preparing light meals and snacks such as cookies, you can even use the two racks at the same time. After all, the convection setting fitted in the appliance will blow the hot air around and ensure that the two meals are hit by hot air equally.
  • Inside the package you will receive from Amazon, you’ll also find several accessories included to make your cooking efforts easier. These accessories include a broiler rack, 2 baking pans, 2 racks, a rotisserie lifter & skewer, and a removable drip tray.

Notable features:

  • Lightweight and portable
  • Compact to save on counter space
  • Durable and sturdy
  • Multiple accessories included
  • The feet are anti-skid
  • The exterior surface remains cool to the touch during operations


At the end of the day, all these best Hamilton Beach toaster ovens will effortlessly meet any home’s toasting needs, requirements, and personal preferences. If, however, you like more than one product and are having a hard time making a final, educated decision based just on the information provided, then allow me to chip in and provide my professional opinion.

If I had to pick from the seven products above, I’d pick the Hamilton Beach 31127D model as my favorite Hamilton beach toaster oven. Its retro style met my personal preferences and its ability to deliver satisfied everyone’s taste in my family.

And what will be the best Hamilton Beach toaster oven in 2022? If you are interested in this subject subscribe us and share your opinion in a comment. Thank you!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

One thought on “The 7 Best Hamilton Beach Toaster Ovens in 2021