The 6 Best Amazon Toaster Ovens in 2021: Tried and Tested Models

If you are tired of leaving your home in a hurry and getting to work or school late because your breakfast took too long to prepare, then a toaster oven is an essential piece of equipment that you will love to have at your corner.

That said, I do understand the main worry that most individuals (probably you included) have when it comes to picking the best out of these appliances. The market is currently filled with millions of toaster ovens, and you would think that makes one’s selection process easier, but it doesn’t. The sheer amount of false advertisement coupled with the lack of website reviews you can trust has turned the simple task of separating the best from the rest into an impossible task – and that’s why I decided to come to your rescue.

To help ease the selection process for you, I went out, tested more than 50 toaster ovens you can find on Amazon, shortlisted them to the best six, and then compiled them into this guide to present them to you. If you are worried about whether the toaster ovens can deliver or not, here is a guide of the features I tested on each product.

• Power of the heating elements
• Sturdiness
• Durability
• Manufacturing brand
• Ease of use
• Ease of cleaning
• Weight
• Cooking speed
• Consistency
• Aesthetics
• Size
• Interior space
• Safety features

As you can see from the exhaustive list above, I went above and beyond to ensure that I only present high-end toaster ovens to you. Better yet, only appliances that passed all the areas above made it into this enumeration, which means that whichever product you pick from the list, you can rest assured that it will meet your home needs and requirements.

In regard to why I only picked products that are available on Amazon, the reasons are endless (and they all have to do with protecting you as a buyer.) For starters, Amazon offers the best prices, it has a huge selection of additional products you can pick from, reliable, boasts fast & cheap shipping, and trusted by millions.

Check out my guide on where you should buy a toaster oven to better understand why ordering through Amazon is a great choice. Without wasting any more of your time, let’s skip to the main section of the post and look at the six best Amazon toaster ovens you can get today.

Oster Toaster Oven

• If you have been following my reviews for a while, then you know that I like starting my posts on a high note; and what can be a better way to start an article on toaster ovens than with a masterpiece from one of the most reputable brands out there today.
• Founded more than 100 years ago, Oster is a leading producer of kitchen appliances and tools that have been specifically designed to make cooks’ lives easier while they are preparing delicious meals. Over the period the company has been in existence, its products have become synonymous with retro designs: and this masterpiece is no different. On your kitchen counter, this Oster Toaster Oven will look like something straight out of the 50s. But do not let that fool you into thinking that the appliance cannot deliver. In fact, if anything it works like something straight out of the future.
• For starters, the unit has been fitted with a digital convection oven. If you’re new to toaster ovens and don’t know what this feature does, it simply implies that the appliance retails with an inbuilt fan that will blow hot air around inside the appliance for fast and even cooking. This cooking setting also ensures that you do not find any cold spots in your cooked meals. That said, as I try to mention in every toaster oven review I create, the convection setting shouldn’t be engaged while cooking every meal. Some foods need to cook slowly and at a lower heat intensity for the best results. While cooking such meals, I recommend that you avoid using the convection setting.
• Other features that have been fitted in this appliance include toast, bake, convection bake, broil, warm, defrost, and pizza. I do not know about you, but these are more than enough to handle the needs of my family.

Notable features

• The exterior surface remains cool to the touch
• Very versatile
• Fitted with a convection technology
• Easy to use and clean
• Lightweight and portable
• Compact to save on kitchen counter space
• Accessories included in the package from Amazon

Breville BOV800XL Toaster Oven

• I first came across this toaster oven model while creating a review on the best industrial toaster ovens. Its ability to deliver impressed me so much that I promised myself that I would always give it a try while creating any review guide where I think it fits. With that in mind, before we get to talking about the appliance’s features, we can both agree that it won’t be stressed by anything your home throws in it. After all, if it can handle the needs and rush hours of commercial settings, your home’s will be a walk in the park.
• Now, moving on. Breville BOV800XL Toaster Oven has been fitted with 9 different preset cooking functions. These include warm, reheat, cookies, pizza, broil, roast, bake, bagel, and toast. The fact that they are preset implies that when you pick one of them, the appliance will automatically adjust the temperature level and timer to levels that ensure the best results. That said, if you have experience using toaster ovens and have a unique recipe that you think will better accommodate your taste, go ahead and use it. And for those who do not trust the appliance’s automatic adjustments but don’t have a recipe of their own, Breville has fixed that for you as well.
• As you can see from the image above, the appliance has been fitted with a resilient, see-through glass door. This will allow you to visually track the cooking progress of your meals. And if you notice through the glass door that your meal has been sufficiently cooked, but the timer is still running, you can simply turn off the appliance and retrieve your meal.
• Another feature worth noting is the fact that the appliance has been backed by a one-year limited product warranty. This is there to show you that the manufacturing company has faith in the model they are selling you, because if anything happens to it within a year, they will fix or replace it at no extra cost to you.

Notable features

• From a reputable brand
• Backed by a one-year limited product warranty
• Very powerful
• Fitted with 5 quartz heating elements
• Comes with 9 preset cooking functions
• Easy to use and clean
• Feet are anti-skid even on wet surfaces

Hamilton Beach 31337D Toaster Oven

• Are you all about designs and you’re looking for an Amazon toaster oven that also doubles up as an aesthetic toaster oven that will leave everyone in awe? If you answered yes to that question, then allow me to introduce you to the Hamilton Beach 31337D Toaster Oven.
• When this product arrived from Amazon, I placed it on multiple kitchen counters with different interior decors and it complemented all of them seamlessly. Better yet, anyone who found the appliance on the kitchen counter inquired about it and wanted to know where they could find a model for their own use.
• The only downside I could find about the appliance’s design is that some people complained about the availability of one color (the red color you can see above.)
• Now let’s look at what the masterpiece can deliver in the toasting department. The appliance’s interior is sufficiently spacious to handle the needs of a small family. It could fit 4 artisan bread slices or a 9” pizza. That also makes it perfect for cooking everything from side dishes to snacks. It also boasts a cool to the touch exterior. This is a must-have feature if you have children or clumsy individuals in your household. If you do not know what a cool-to-the-touch exterior is, it simply implies that regardless of how long the appliance stays in operation, its exterior surface will not get hot: which in turn means that anyone who comes into contact with it won’t sustain any serious burn injuries.
• We have to talk about the roll-top door too. As you can see from the image above, unlike other toaster ovens whose doors open downwards, this machine’s opens upwards. This means that you won’t be able to cause spillage on it while retrieving your meals, which in turn makes cleaning sessions easier.

Notable features:

• Has a cool design
• Spacious interior
• Made from durable material
• Lightweight and portable
• Compact to save on kitchen counter space
• Boasts 2 rack positions to improve your flexibility
• Has a roll-top door design

Cuisinart TOB-40N Toaster Oven

• This guide on the best Amazon toaster ovens would be incomplete without at least one product from Cuisinart. Founded in Chicago in 1973 by Carl Sontheimer, Cuisinart is an American home appliance brand best known for its durable units – and this Cuisinart TOB-40N Toaster Oven is no exception.
• While testing the product, I reached out to two friends who I know have been using the exact same model for years now to know if they recommended it to someone else. They both claimed that over the years they have owned the appliances, they have never run into any issues.
• To help it handle anything you throw in it, this masterpiece has been fitted with 1800 watts of power. The stainless-steel material used to construct the appliance is also very durable. My daughter has knocked down the model I acquired a few times, but that hasn’t affected its ability to deliver in any way, shape, or form.

Notable features:

• Retails from a reputable brand
• Its exterior surface remains cool to the touch
• Feet are anti-skid
• The power cord is sufficiently long
• The interior surface is coated with a nonstick material
• Very powerful and durable
• Easy to use and clean

Mueller Austria Toaster Oven

• Mueller Austria Toaster Oven is a classic and cool little beast in the realm of toaster ovens retailing with a shiny polished finish that will look aesthetic on any kitchen counter. Add to that its good-looking knobs and you have one of the best aesthetic toaster ovens.
• It has also been fitted with an even-toast technology. This means that unlike convection toaster ovens that retail with an inbuilt fan to blow hot air around, this appliance’s interior is naturally designed to push hot air around equally and in all directions. The even-toast technology will not only ensure fast and even cooking but will also ensure you never find any cold spots in your cooked meals.
• Inside the package you will receive from Amazon, you’ll find two accessories, including a multi-purpose pan and a removable crumb tray (which will help in cleaning.) If you’re not familiar with a crumb tray, it’s the one responsible for collecting all the dirt and debris that fall off of your cooked food. To clean the crumb tray, simply take it out, empty its content into a bin or sink, and wipe it clean using a damp cloth.

Notable features:

• Has a natural convection design
• Delivers 1100 watts of power
• It’s fitted with a 30-minute timer
• Boasts two rack positions
• Very versatile
• Interior light included

BLACK+DECKER TO1675B Toaster Oven

• The last, but by no means the least, Amazon toaster oven in our enumeration is also from one of the leading brands in the kitchen appliances industry. Established in 1910 in Maryland, Black & Decker is a leading American manufacturer best known for its kitchen appliances, home improvement products, fastener systems, hardware, accessories, and power tools.
• The number of years they have been in existence, coupled with the fact the company has spread its wings that much should show you that they know what they’re doing. That’s further proved by this BLACK+DECKER TO1675B Toaster Oven’s ability to deliver.
• While testing the product, I used it to toast more than 200 bread slices back-to-back, and without letting the appliance rest. The last one to go inside the appliance came out just as perfectly and evenly toasted as the first one to go in. It also delivered every slice in less than 3 minutes, which is honestly as fast as some of the fastest toaster ovens I’ve had the pleasure of testing.

Notable features:

• Cooks fast
• Very powerful
• Fitted with a convection setting
• Boasts a removable crumb tray
• Has a 60-minute timer
• The power cord is sufficiently long

After extensive research sessions and testing procedures, I personally vote for the Breville BOV800XL as the best Amazon toaster oven from the list above. This tool is perfect for people who have a family and are looking for a unit that can serve them for years.

As I mentioned, the product has also been backed by a one-year limited product warranty. If the company is willing to boost your confidence before buying their product, you can rest assured that they went above and beyond to design a product that will exceed your requirements.

And what will be the best Amazon toaster oven in 2022? If you are interested in this subject subscribe us and share your opinion in a comment. Thank you!