We'd like to recommend you the best products! We may get a small share of the sale should you buy something through our recommendation links.

The 6 Best Amazon Prime Toaster Ovens in 2021

Best Amazon prime toaster ovens

Nowadays, I cannot imagine my breakfast without a single serving of peanut butter cookies. I bet there are meals you can’t do without either, which proves that toaster ovens have become a staple part of our daily lives today.

That said, my ability to enjoy my peanut butter cookies was hindered slightly when my beloved toaster oven broke down and I realized how hard it was to find a unit that was as reliable as the previous one. Sure, the market is flooded with thousands (if not hundreds of thousands) of toaster ovens, but the number of false advertisements made it almost impossible to separate the best from the rest.

If this is the situation you’re in at the moment, then worry not. I’m here to help you out.

To help you counter this new hindrance in your life, I set out into the marketplace before you on a quest to find the best toaster ovens that can accommodate anyone’s personal preferences and cooking requirements.

Better yet, I only reviewed toaster ovens available on Amazon Prime, which is a deal you need to have if you love shopping and like to explore new sale offers. Advantages of acquiring products from Amazon Prime include:

  • Unlimited ad-free access to station, playlists, and millions of albums and songs at no additional cost
  • Unlimited streaming of the latest movies and award-winning Amazon originals
  • Exclusive deals of the day
  • Prime-exclusive deals – exclusive lightning deals
  • Prime early access. Get early access to lightning deals
  • Free same-day delivery to eligible addresses
  • Free scheduled delivery to eligible addresses
  • Free no-rush shipping to eligible addresses
  • Free two-day delivery to eligible addresses
  • Free one day delivery to eligible addresses

If those advantages do not convince you to invest in Amazon Prime, I do not know what will.

To ensure that every single toaster oven in this enumeration will meet your toasting needs and requirements, I also took the appliances through a series of tests and picked only the ones that exceeded my expectations.

This means that whichever Amazon Prime toaster oven you pick from the list, you can rest assured that its ability to deliver won’t be disappointing you.

The Top 6 Best Amazon Prime Toaster Ovens in 2021

Toaster Oven NameWeightTimerDimensionsSlicePrice
Convection Toaster Oven Airfryer1 lbsYes14 x 15.75 x 14 in8 Check Price
Mini Smart Oven15.2 lbsYes16 x 14.25 x 8.5 in8 Check Price
COMFEE' Toaster Oven7.68 lbsYes16.25 x 13.2 x 10.1 in4 Check Price
Convection Countertop Toaster Oven15.25 lbsYes15.75 x 24.45 x 13.7 in4 Check Price
2-in-1 Countertop Oven10.9 lbsYes12.05 x 17.8 x 10.24 in4 Check Price
Luby Large Toaster Oven24.9 lbsYes22.04 x 16.14 x 14.37 in8 Check Price

Amazon Prime Toaster Oven #1:

  • Do you have a loved one’s wedding or party coming up and you’re looking for a unit that also doubles up as a perfect gift option? If yes, then allow me to introduce you to the Cuisinart TOA-60BKS Toaster Oven. This unit retails in four different colors, namely black, copper, cream, and silver. This improves your chances of getting the appliance in the recipient’s favorite color.
  • The appliance didn’t disappoint in the toasting department either. The unit has been fitted with 1800 watts of power, which is more than capable to handle anything your family throws in it. In fact, I know three friends who own a catering business and one of them uses this exact Cuisinart model in his business.
  • When I reached out to him to ask about the appliance’s performance and whether he would recommend it to anyone, he said that he would not only recommend it, but he has also been using the unit for years now and it had never run into any issues during this period.
  • To back up this high level of power, it has also been fitted with 7 different cooking functions, namely toast, warm, bake, broil, convection bake, convection broil, and air fry setting. There are at least two cooking functions worth touching on in that list.
  • The first one is the convection setting. if you’re new to toaster ovens, this implies that Cuisinart TOA-60BKS Toaster Oven retails with an inbuilt fan that will blow hot air around inside the appliance for fast and even results. This feature also ensures you do not find any cold spots on your meals. That said, while I do know that the setting sounds appealing, I feel like I ought to mention that you shouldn’t engage the convection setting while cooking every single meal. Some foods like cakes and pizza slices need to cook slowly and at a low heat intensity, so avoid engaging the convection setting while cooking these meals.
  • Here is a guide on how to bake using a toaster oven to show you the different levels you should engage the convection setting.
  • The second cooking setting worth noting is the air-fry feature. This implies that unlike regular toaster ovens, this one will use hot air instead of oil to deep fry your meals. So, if your goal this year is to eat healthier and hit that body goal, this is the appliance for you. The results, using the air-fry setting will not only be healthier but crispier too, creating delicious meals.
  • Accessories you will find in the package from Amazon include an air fryer basket, air fryer rack, baking pan, and an oven rack.

Notable features

  • Retails from a reputable brand
  • Fitted with an air-fry setting
  • Boasts convection technology
  • Easy to use and clean
  • Very powerful
  • Included different accessories

Amazon Prime Toaster Oven #2:

  • If this review wasn’t about Amazon Prime toaster ovens, I think another title that would perfectly fit the post would be “the most powerful toaster ovens.” Just like the Cuisinart toaster oven we just looked at, this Breville BOV450XL has been fitted with 1800 watts of power to handle anything you throw in it. Couple this with the 4-quartz IQ heating elements and you have one of the fastest toaster ovens in the market.
  • It has also been fitted with 8 pre-set cooking functions, including toast, bake, broil, roast, cookies, reheat, pizza, and bagel. The fact they are preset implies that when you select one of them, the appliance will automatically adjust the temperature level and timer to a combination that ensures perfect results.
  • How could we end the toaster’s review without touching on the fact that the appliance has been backed by a one-year limited product warranty? This one is there to boost your confidence and show you that the manufacturing brand has faith in the product they are selling you.

Notable features

  • Very powerful
  • Heating elements are of the highest quality
  • Includes a backlit easy read LCD
  • Comes with 8 cooking functions
  • Cooks fast
  • Will look aesthetic on the kitchen counter
  • The feet are anti-skid on wet surfaces
  • Boasts a non-stick interior cavity coating

Amazon Prime Toaster Oven #3:

  • If like most people, you do not care about bells and whistles and you’re only looking for an Amazon Prime toaster oven that can deliver what it’s advertised to do, then this COMFEE’ CFO-BB101 is exactly what you’re looking for. Note though, this doesn’t mean that this toaster oven is the ugliest in the realm of kitchen appliances. In fact, if anything, it has one of the best retro designs. What I’m trying to say is that straight out of the box, you’ll either love or hate its design.
  • Immediately after visiting the product’s page on Amazon, one of the first things you will notice is that the appliance also retails in three different colors, namely black, silver, and white. These improve your chances of getting it in a shade that perfectly complements your kitchen interior décor.

Notable features:

  • From a reputable brand
  • Retails in three different colors
  • Compact to save on kitchen counter space
  • Feet are anti-skid on wet surfaces
  • The exterior surface remains cool to the touch during operations
  • Lightweight and portable

Amazon Prime Toaster Oven #4:

  • This guide on the best Amazon Prime toaster ovens would be incomplete without at least one masterpiece from Black and Decker. Founded in 1910 in Maryland, Black+Decker is an American manufacturer best known for its durable kitchen appliances, fastener systems, home improvement products, hardware, accessories, and power tools. This BLACK+DECKER TO3240XSBD Toaster Oven is no different.
  • If you checked out my guide on how to pick the best toaster oven, you also remember that one of the tips I mentioned is separating the best models from the rest by sorting them out according to their manufacturing brands.
  • Consequently, ensure you pick a unit from a reputable brand because unlike lesser-known brands, leading ones have a reputation to maintain, which means that they will go above and beyond to ensure that the product that they release to the public will work as advertised.

Notable features:

  • Convection heating
  • Has a dedicated toast timer
  • Has a wide temperature range
  • Has a sturdy build
  • Durable and powerful
  • Boasts an extra-wide interior
  • The power cord is sufficiently long

Amazon Prime Toaster Oven #5:

  • In the realm of kitchen appliances, Hamilton Beach has quite a reputation for its ability to design cooking appliances that are easy to use and convenient. In fact, the company has been in operation for decades now, which implies that they have a pretty good idea of what their clients want.
  • After extensively testing this Hamilton Beach 31156 Toaster Oven model, it lived up to its manufacturing brand’s reputation. As you can see from the image above, the appliance has also been fitted with a separate slot on the top side, which can deliver delicious toasties in less than two minutes. It has also been fitted with a 60-minute timer and auto shut off feature. The auto shut off feature will turn the oven off when the baking time you have set runs down. This means that there is no need to worry about overcooking or leaving your oven on.

Notable features:

  • 60-minute timer
  • Has a separate shade selector
  • Boasts a cool to the touch exterior
  • Cooks fast
  • Feet are anti-skid
  • Has a non-stick interior
  • Has a separate slot on top

Amazon Prime Toaster Oven #6:

  • Luby Large Toaster Oven’s unique selling proposition is obvious just from its name. The unit’s spacious interior is sufficient to bake a family cake, a nice tenderloin, roast a 20-lbs. turkey, bake a 14-inch pizza, or comfortably fit a 24-inch muffin tray.
  • Inside the package you will receive from Amazon, you’ll also find several accessories including a tray handle, wire rack, and a baking tray. All these have been put in there to improve your flexibility in the kitchen.
  • The nonstick interior surfaces will ensure that the foods you cook do not stick to them, which in turn makes your cleaning sessions easier. Couple that with the removable crumb tray the appliance retails with and you have one of the best easy to clean toaster ovens.

Notable features:

  • Extremely spacious interior
  • Accessories included in the package
  • French door designed
  • Fitted with a 60-minute timer
  • Fast and even heating
  • It will look good on any kitchen counter


After extensive research and testing sessions, I personally pick the first, Cuisinart TOA-60BKS as my favorite Amazon prime toaster oven in the market in today. This stroke of genius boasted everything one needed to accommodate the needs of a cooking enthusiast as well as professional chefs without a hassle.

And what will be the best Amazon Prime toaster oven in 2022? If you are interested in this subject subscribe us and share your opinion in a comment. Thank you!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.